Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Statistics 2008

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This page presents arbitration data and statistics for 2008. For other years see:


Requests[edit]

  • Legend: A=Accept, D=Decline, R=Recuse, C=Comment, I=Inactive/away, N=Not eligible

Case requests[edit]

  • Requests: 152; average duration: 4.6 days; accepted: 35 (23%); declined: 102 (67%); disposed by motion: 2 (1% ); withdrawn: 13 (9%).
Case requests involving 2008 arbs only
Request Opened Closed Days Disp A D R C I Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg Kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Moreschi 22:43, 16-Dec-2008 14:58, 20-Dec-2008 4 Motion 1 5 3 2 0 R D C R D R D D D N A C N
Cirt, Jehochman, and Qwerty612 07:51, 28-Nov-2008 12:17, 30-Nov-2008 2 Declined 0 5 0 0 0 D D D D N D N
ScienceApologist 2 23:42, 26-Nov-2008 00:24, 27-Nov-2008 0 Withdrawn 0 0 0 2 1 C I N C N
Edits by User:Jörg ÖA 05:40, 20-Nov-2008 20:54, 23-Nov-2008 4 Withdrawn 0 4 0 0 2 I D I D D N D N
David Gerard 23:12, 18-Nov-2008 01:30, 22-Nov-2008 3 Declined 0 6 2 1 1 R D D I R D D N D D N C
Removal Woods results by Ronz 21:40, 14-Nov-2008 00:31, 18-Nov-2008 3 Declined 0 4 0 0 2 D I D I D D N N
Bennett Lebow 15:10, 15-Nov-2008 13:21, 17-Nov-2008 2 Declined 0 4 0 0 2 I D I D D N D N
Cold fusion 19:33, 12-Nov-2008 15:21, 14-Nov-2008 2 Accepted 7 0 0 0 1 A A I A A A N A A N
Aspartame_controversy 04:53, 7-Nov-2008 14:29, 11-Nov-2008 4 Declined 0 6 0 0 3 D I I D I D D D N D N
Adraeus v. Deacon of Pndapetzim … 11:31, 29-Oct-2008 05:27, 7-Nov-2008 9 Declined 0 4 0 0 3 D I I D I D N D N
Arjun MBT 06:00, 28-Oct-2008 05:26, 7-Nov-2008 10 Declined 0 4 0 0 3 I I D I D D N D N
Kuban Kazak-Hillock65 04:30, 30-Oct-2008 00:14, 5-Nov-2008 6 Accepted 5 0 0 0 3 A I I A I A A N A N
Wizardman's closure of the Ginger Jolie deletion debate 00:59, 21-Oct-2008 19:36, 27-Oct-2008 7 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 I D D D D N D N
Request for desysop and block of administrator Hemanshu 02:18, 20-Oct-2008 01:05, 21-Oct-2008 1 Declined 0 5 0 0 2 I I D D D N D N D
Tax liens and Joe the Plumber 00:52, 18-Oct-2008 01:02, 21-Oct-2008 3 Declined 0 5 0 0 2 I I D D D N D D N
Madonna Blond Ambition Tour Title Dispute 16:31, 17-Oct-2008 04:33, 20-Oct-2008 3 Declined 0 5 0 0 2 I I D D D N D D N
Virgin America Focus City Dispute 02:21, 12-Oct-2008 13:02, 15-Oct-2008 3 Declined 0 5 0 0 2 I I D D D N D D N
Abtract-Collectonian 20:26, 11-Oct-2008 12:06, 15-Oct-2008 4 Accepted 5 0 0 0 2 I I A A A N A A N
Unapproved admin bots 19:08, 17-Sep-2008 20:44, 25-Sep-2008 8 Motion 2 6 0 2 2 I I C D D D A A D C N D D N
Racism section at Controversies regarding Jehovah's Witnesses 17:25, 17-Sep-2008 18:55, 20-Sep-2008 3 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I I D D D D N D I
Topic Ban of Benjiboi 10:53, 8-Sep-2008 20:13, 17-Sep-2008 9 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I I D D D D N D I
Supreme Court and U.S. code quotes 16:30, 8-Sep-2008 08:33, 14-Sep-2008 6 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I I D D D N D D I
Preventing edit on Arjun MBT page 15:17, 11-Sep-2008 08:33, 14-Sep-2008 3 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I I D D D N D D I
Georgewilliamherbert 20:21, 1-Sep-2008 03:23, 12-Sep-2008 10 Declined 3 4 0 3 3 I I A A D C D C C N D A I D
Jfdwolff 15:55, 6-Sep-2008 09:44, 10-Sep-2008 4 Declined 0 0 0 0 2 I N I
Chrislk02 00:00, 6-Sep-2008 04:43, 9-Sep-2008 3 Declined 0 5 1 0 2 I D D D R N D D I
Sarah Palin protection wheel war 17:30, 4-Sep-2008 20:26, 5-Sep-2008 1 Accepted 6 0 0 0 2 I A A A A N A A I
Majorly 18:26, 2-Sep-2008 22:02, 3-Sep-2008 1 Declined 1 5 0 0 2 I D D D A D N D I
Jehochman, Elonka, ChrisO 07:35, 29-Aug-2008 23:59, 30-Aug-2008 2 Withdrawn 0 2 1 3 2 I C C D C N D R I
Piotrus 2 09:45, 26-Aug-2008 21:33, 29-Aug-2008 3 Accepted 7 0 0 0 2 I A A A A A N A A I
Eastern Mediterranean University 06:26, 27-Aug-2008 23:19, 28-Aug-2008 2 Declined 0 6 0 0 2 I D D D D N D D I
Elonka 20:15, 23-Aug-2008 02:29, 28-Aug-2008 4 Declined 2 4 3 2 1 D R C A D D A D C N R R I
Tenmei and Nick Dowling 02:42, 7-Aug-2008 02:37, 11-Aug-2008 4 Declined 0 4 0 0 1 D D D D N I
User:Alastair Haines 02:03, 6-Aug-2008 01:44, 8-Aug-2008 2 Accepted 6 0 0 0 1 A A A A N A A I
Ethnic minorities in Iran (and associated articles) 14:16, 5-Aug-2008 12:05, 6-Aug-2008 1 Withdrawn 0 3 0 0 1 D D N I D
Kurt M. Weber 14:39, 4-Aug-2008 00:22, 6-Aug-2008 1 Declined 0 6 0 0 1 D D D N D D I D
Bedford 15:45, 28-Jul-2008 23:52, 3-Aug-2008 6 Declined 4 5 0 0 1 D D A D D A N D A A I
User:Rschen7754 23:30, 29-Jul-2008 17:02, 30-Jul-2008 1 Withdrawn 0 4 0 0 1 D D D N D I
Barack Obama 18:32, 27-Jul-2008 14:48, 29-Jul-2008 2 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 D D D D D N D D I
SlimVirgin-Lar 13:36, 20-Jul-2008 04:37, 23-Jul-2008 3 Accepted 6 0 0 2 1 A A C A A N C A A I
Gerald Guterman 03:27, 16-Jul-2008 19:49, 18-Jul-2008 3 Declined 0 6 0 0 1 D D D D D N D I
Guido den Broeder 23:03, 14-Jul-2008 02:13, 17-Jul-2008 2 Declined 0 4 0 1 1 D C D N D D I
Bardcom 10:02, 8-Jul-2008 16:18, 16-Jul-2008 8 Declined 1 5 0 0 1 A D D N D D D I
Arthur Rubin desysop 19:44, 7-Jul-2008 07:14, 10-Jul-2008 2 Declined 0 6 0 0 2 I D D D D N D D I
Gerald Guterman 04:02, 7-Jul-2008 09:12, 8-Jul-2008 1 Declined 0 4 0 0 2 I D D D N D I
Wheelwar regarding User:Giano II 23:04, 1-Jul-2008 01:39, 3-Jul-2008 1 Accepted 6 2 1 0 2 A I R A A A N D A A I D
OrangeMarlin 16:50, 29-Jun-2008 00:46, 2-Jul-2008 2 Declined 0 4 0 0 2 I D D D D N I
FT2 05:39, 30-Jun-2008 10:24, 30-Jun-2008 0 Withdrawn 0 1 0 0 2 I N I D
User:Yorkshirian on "ethnic cleansing" 20:49, 25-Jun-2008 18:33, 28-Jun-2008 3 Accepted 4 0 0 0 3 A I I A N I A A
Evolutionary psychology 17:59, 16-Jun-2008 14:27, 24-Jun-2008 8 Declined 0 3 0 1 3 D I I C D N I D
Desysop of User:Can't sleep, clown will eat me 20:45, 12-Jun-2008 02:10, 16-Jun-2008 3 Declined 0 4 0 0 3 D I D I D D N I
Intelligent design editors 01:37, 30-May-2008 01:09, 15-Jun-2008 16 Declined 1 4 0 3 2 D I A I C D D N C C D
SevenOfDiamonds 2 01:34, 6-Jun-2008 01:04, 15-Jun-2008 9 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I D I D D D N I D
Dzonatas 04:12, 6-Jun-2008 23:57, 11-Jun-2008 6 Withdrawn 0 6 0 0 3 I I D D D D D N I D
Pilotguy 17:45, 3-Jun-2008 15:53, 5-Jun-2008 2 Declined 0 5 0 0 2 D I D D D N I D
Attachment theory 08:00, 28-May-2008 13:24, 29-May-2008 1 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 D I D D N D D
Zscout370 17:25, 28-May-2008 05:36, 29-May-2008 1 Withdrawn 0 3 0 0 1 I D D N D
Moulton 20:35, 25-May-2008 02:54, 29-May-2008 3 Declined 0 4 1 1 1 D C I D R D N D
Betacommand 3 17:43, 24-May-2008 23:44, 26-May-2008 2 Declined 0 5 0 0 0 D D N D D D
Generation X 12:32, 23-May-2008 23:30, 25-May-2008 2 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 D I D D N D D
JzG 09:16, 18-May-2008 20:57, 25-May-2008 7 Accepted 0 0 0 4 1 C I C C N C
Dispute w' user Wikidemo Deleting Webby Awards Criticisms 08:14, 22-May-2008 09:00, 25-May-2008 3 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 I D D N D D D
User: Chrisjnelson and "Originally" 19:43, 21-May-2008 05:23, 25-May-2008 3 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 D I D D N D D
Allegations of state terrorism by the United States 04:48, 13-May-2008 01:25, 18-May-2008 5 Declined 0 4 0 0 1 I D D D N D
Anti-Americanism 07:54, 12-May-2008 02:52, 17-May-2008 5 Declined 0 4 0 0 1 I D D D N D
The_undertow 21:45, 14-May-2008 10:03, 16-May-2008 2 Declined 0 0 0 4 1 I C N C C C
Cla68, FeloniousMonk, and SlimVirgin 18:19, 14-May-2008 11:20, 16-May-2008 2 Accepted 4 0 1 0 1 I A A R N A A
ChrisO 00:53, 7-May-2008 10:26, 14-May-2008 7 Declined 0 3 0 0 0 D D D N
Ulster Defence Regiment 19:36, 29-Apr-2008 09:54, 8-May-2008 9 Declined 0 5 0 0 0 D D D N D D
User:SaltyBoatr 20:21, 29-Apr-2008 01:33, 6-May-2008 6 Declined 0 5 0 0 0 D D D N D D
Giovanni33 22:05, 1-May-2008 22:57, 4-May-2008 3 Accepted 4 0 0 0 0 A A A N A
User:Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) and footnote quotes 10:41, 28-Apr-2008 16:10, 4-May-2008 6 Accepted 4 0 0 1 0 C A A A N A
Request to lift article ban 16:45, 24-Apr-2008 00:38, 4-May-2008 9 Declined 0 5 0 0 0 D D D N D D
User:William M. Connolley 14:08, 26-Apr-2008 00:35, 4-May-2008 7 Declined 4 4 0 0 0 D A A D A N D A D
List of projects supported by George Soros 02:17, 29-Apr-2008 16:35, 1-May-2008 3 Declined 0 6 0 0 0 D D D N D D D
CAMERA lobbying 16:15, 23-Apr-2008 21:53, 29-Apr-2008 6 Accepted 7 2 0 0 0 D D A A A N A A A A
JoshuaZ 17:14, 22-Apr-2008 01:02, 29-Apr-2008 6 Declined 0 4 1 1 0 D D C R D D
Floyd McKissick, Jr. 17:33, 21-Apr-2008 14:39, 27-Apr-2008 6 Declined 0 6 0 0 0 D D D D D D
Melissa Farley 03:23, 19-Apr-2008 14:33, 26-Apr-2008 7 Declined 0 5 0 0 0 D D D D D
Appeal of commuity ban of Iantresman 10:07, 10-Apr-2008 00:40, 23-Apr-2008 13 Declined 2 4 0 0 0 D A D A D D
South Slavic Diacritics 07:36, 16-Apr-2008 09:48, 21-Apr-2008 5 Declined 0 4 0 0 1 D I D D D
ScienceApologist/JzG 04:22, 12-Apr-2008 09:48, 21-Apr-2008 9 Declined 0 4 0 1 1 C I D D D D
Tango 21:17, 12-Apr-2008 11:00, 19-Apr-2008 7 Accepted 6 2 2 2 1 A I D A A D C R A R C A A
DanaUllman 01:15, 17-Apr-2008 09:58, 19-Apr-2008 2 Accepted 5 0 0 0 2 A I A A I A A
Egyptians 07:30, 6-Apr-2008 11:22, 10-Apr-2008 4 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 I D D D D D
IZAK 2 17:23, 2-Apr-2008 02:00, 9-Apr-2008 6 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 I D D D D D
WP:NCGN 00:09, 3-Apr-2008 01:43, 7-Apr-2008 4 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 I D D D D D
Davenbelle 21:42, 1-Apr-2008 14:31, 5-Apr-2008 4 Declined 0 5 0 0 1 I D D D D D
Teen Challenge 04:14, 1-Apr-2008 00:47, 4-Apr-2008 3 Declined 0 6 0 0 2 I D D D D I D D
Episode images 13:11, 28-Mar-2008 22:36, 1-Apr-2008 4 Declined 0 6 0 0 2 D I D D D D I D
Strider12 22:25, 28-Mar-2008 21:51, 1-Apr-2008 4 Accepted 5 0 0 0 2 I A A A A A I
Wikipedia Sexist Editing in Child Psychology 01:14, 27-Mar-2008 03:19, 30-Mar-2008 3 Declined 0 5 1 0 2 I D R D D D I D
International Churches of Christ 08:32, 26-Mar-2008 13:25, 28-Mar-2008 2 Accepted 5 0 0 0 2 I A A A I A A
Theresa Lopez-Fitzgerald 02:58, 26-Mar-2008 16:01, 28-Mar-2008 3 Declined 0 7 0 0 2 I D D D D I D D D
Jack Merridew 19:06, 13-Mar-2008 22:49, 26-Mar-2008 13 Declined 2 4 0 0 2 I A D D D A I D
Rjecina (ban appeal re WP:ARBMAC) 22:43, 20-Mar-2008 02:00, 25-Mar-2008 4 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 I D D D D D D D
Lir 01:25, 24-Mar-2008 23:01, 24-Mar-2008 1 Declined 0 7 0 0 2 I D D D D D I D D
Illyrians 22:51, 19-Mar-2008 02:23, 23-Mar-2008 3 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 I D D D D D D D
9/11 conspiracy theories 21:47, 17-Mar-2008 19:12, 19-Mar-2008 2 Accepted 6 0 2 0 1 A I A A A R A R A
Prem Rawat 20:29, 16-Mar-2008 02:20, 18-Mar-2008 1 Accepted 6 0 1 0 1 R I A A A A A A
User:Mackan79 21:38, 16-Mar-2008 16:00, 17-Mar-2008 1 Declined 0 6 0 0 1 I D D D D D D
Appeal of topic ban for User:Whig 17:04, 14-Mar-2008 02:53, 17-Mar-2008 2 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 I D D D D D D D
BetacommandBot 23:57, 7-Mar-2008 15:32, 16-Mar-2008 9 Accepted 7 0 1 1 1 I R C A A A A A A A
Mate.Feed.Kill.Repeat 18:07, 11-Mar-2008 23:40, 13-Mar-2008 2 Declined 0 6 0 0 0 D D D D D D
Misapplication of WP:BIRD 22:05, 2-Mar-2008 01:20, 8-Mar-2008 5 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 D D D I D D D D
Mikkalai 06:21, 1-Mar-2008 04:30, 6-Mar-2008 5 Declined 4 5 0 0 1 D A D A I A A D D D
Russian apartment Bombings 09:03, 26-Feb-2008 05:40, 2-Mar-2008 5 Declined 0 6 0 0 1 D D I D D D D
Arabic Network for Human Rights Information 16:24, 28-Feb-2008 00:31, 1-Mar-2008 1 Withdrawn 0 4 0 0 1 D D I D D
Linguistic/Cultural Bias Towards United States in "Hacker" 06:14, 20-Feb-2008 04:29, 26-Feb-2008 6 Declined 0 4 0 1 0 C D D D D
WSYX-TV Dispute 16:24, 17-Feb-2008 22:51, 22-Feb-2008 5 Declined 0 5 0 0 0 D D D D D
New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures 04:18, 8-Feb-2008 21:15, 22-Feb-2008 15 Accepted 4 0 1 2 0 C A A C A A R
JzG 01:59, 11-Feb-2008 21:24, 15-Feb-2008 5 Declined 0 7 0 0 0 D D D D D D D
Ukrainian Insurgent Army 16:34, 7-Feb-2008 11:06, 14-Feb-2008 7 Declined 0 6 0 0 0 D D D D D D
Mantanmoreland 20:41, 13-Feb-2008 22:50, 14-Feb-2008 1 Accepted 6 0 1 0 1 I A A R A A A A
Plain English Campaign 18:49, 5-Feb-2008 17:05, 12-Feb-2008 7 Declined 0 8 0 0 2 I D D D D D I D D D
ABCCL deletion 21:47, 4-Feb-2008 23:58, 10-Feb-2008 6 Declined 0 8 0 0 2 I D D D D I D D D D
Canada, Canada's Name and Dominion 11:14, 6-Feb-2008 21:25, 7-Feb-2008 1 Withdrawn 0 1 0 2 2 I D I C C
Chuck Marean - Gwernol 19:39, 1-Feb-2008 10:41, 6-Feb-2008 5 Declined 0 7 0 0 2 I D D D D I D D D
Interchange Fee 00:00, 1-Feb-2008 10:40, 6-Feb-2008 5 Declined 0 7 0 0 2 I D D D D D I D D
Franco-Mongol alliance 15:07, 26-Jan-2008 22:02, 5-Feb-2008 10 Accepted 7 2 0 0 2 I A A A A I A D A A D
Homeopathy 11:12, 28-Jan-2008 23:02, 3-Feb-2008 6 Declined 0 4 0 0 3 I D I D D I D
Alice 22:28, 26-Jan-2008 12:34, 2-Feb-2008 7 Declined 0 4 0 0 4 I D I D I D D I
Jeffrey O. Gustafson 2 20:11, 24-Jan-2008 16:27, 31-Jan-2008 7 Declined 0 7 0 0 4 I D I D D I D D D I D
Ehud Lesar 07:09, 18-Jan-2008 02:36, 30-Jan-2008 12 Accepted 6 2 0 1 3 I A A C A D I A A I A D
Webby Awards 00:29, 20-Jan-2008 18:50, 25-Jan-2008 6 Declined 0 6 0 0 3 I I D D D D D D I
SPOV and civility in fringe articles 05:10, 18-Jan-2008 02:03, 24-Jan-2008 6 Declined 0 4 0 0 3 I I D D D D I
Rachel Marsden 2 17:17, 20-Jan-2008 23:14, 22-Jan-2008 2 Declined 0 3 0 0 3 I I D D D I
Austrian economics 15:11, 13-Jan-2008 21:00, 21-Jan-2008 8 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I I D D D D D I
Asian fetish 08:29, 13-Jan-2008 20:43, 21-Jan-2008 9 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I I D D D D D I
Sorcerer's Stone vs. Philosopher's Stone 02:36, 20-Jan-2008 05:44, 20-Jan-2008 0 Withdrawn 0 3 0 0 3 I I D D D I
The Television Episodes Edit Wars 02:34, 14-Jan-2008 21:39, 19-Jan-2008 6 Accepted 4 0 0 0 4 I I A A A I A I
Rollback consensus 00:45, 11-Jan-2008 14:02, 19-Jan-2008 9 Declined 1 4 0 1 4 I I C A D D D I D I
David Howe (claimant to King of Mann) 03:26, 10-Jan-2008 00:54, 18-Jan-2008 8 Accepted 5 1 0 1 3 I I A A C A A I D A
Plovdiv external link 00:26, 15-Jan-2008 22:52, 17-Jan-2008 3 Declined 0 8 0 0 2 I I D D D D D D D D
Elvis Presley / Onefortyone 16:10, 7-Jan-2008 14:54, 15-Jan-2008 8 Declined 0 3 0 4 3 I I D C C C C D D I
Extraordinary rendtion by the United States 20:26, 8-Jan-2008 22:53, 14-Jan-2008 6 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 I D D D D D D D
Waterboarding 11:39, 10-Jan-2008 16:27, 13-Jan-2008 3 Accepted 5 0 0 0 2 I A A A I A A
Principality of Sealand 19:34, 9-Jan-2008 10:12, 12-Jan-2008 3 Withdrawn 0 3 0 1 1 I D D C D
User:R. fiend 22:38, 9-Jan-2008 23:54, 11-Jan-2008 2 Accepted 6 0 0 0 2 I A A A A A I A
Anti-Dominicanism 19:22, 4-Jan-2008 23:24, 11-Jan-2008 7 Declined 1 6 0 0 1 I D D D D D A D
Armenia-Azerbaijan 3 17:41, 4-Jan-2008 03:47, 11-Jan-2008 6 Declined 1 5 0 0 1 I D A D D D D
Palestine-Israel conflict 17:03, 8-Jan-2008 21:50, 10-Jan-2008 2 Accepted 4 0 0 0 1 I A A A A
Ireland national football team (IFA) 23:29, 4-Jan-2008 07:42, 9-Jan-2008 4 Declined 0 7 0 0 1 I D D D D D D D
Matt Sanchez 04:03, 6-Jan-2008 21:40, 7-Jan-2008 2 Accepted 4 0 0 0 1 I A A A A
Thomas Basboll 10:04, 31-Dec-2007 14:07, 6-Jan-2008 6 Declined 0 6 2 0 1 I D D D R D R D D
BlueAzure 19:50, 26-Dec-2007 07:26, 4-Jan-2008 8 Declined 0 6 0 0 3 I D D D D D D I I
Lavvu 06:52, 26-Dec-2007 00:07, 3-Jan-2008 8 Declined 0 5 0 0 3 I D D D D D I I
NE2 03:24, 29-Dec-2007 22:10, 2-Jan-2008 5 Accepted 5 0 1 1 3 I A A A R A C I A I
Jim62sch 01:36, 1-Jan-2008 17:40, 2-Jan-2008 2 Accepted 7 0 0 0 3 I A A A A A I A A I
John Gohde 2 18:04, 30-Dec-2007 06:30, 2-Jan-2008 3 Accepted 4 0 0 0 3 I A A A A I I
ST47 06:06, 1-Jan-2008 20:23, 1-Jan-2008 1 Withdrawn 0 5 0 0 3 I D D D D D I I
Zeraeph 17:38, 29-Dec-2007 19:20, 1-Jan-2008 3 Accepted 5 0 1 0 3 I A A A A R I A I

Clarifications and other requests[edit]

  • Requests: 103; average duration: 14.6 days; declined: 40 (39%); disposed by clarification: 34 (33%); disposed by motion: 19 (18%); disposed by case: 1 (1%); withdrawn: 7 (7%); removed: 2 (2%).
Clarifications and other requests involving 2008 arbs only
Request Opened Closed Days Disp R C I Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg Kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Clarify Peter Damian 21:19, 5-Dec-2008 23:58, 17-Dec-2008 12 Motion 0 5 1 C C I C C C N N
Amend : Alastair Haines 01:12, 23-Nov-2008 23:46, 17-Dec-2008 25 Motion 0 2 1 C I C N N
Amend : Matthew Hoffman 14:37, 12-Nov-2008 06:22, 16-Dec-2008 34 Motion 0 4 0 C C N C C N
Amend : Bluemarine 06:08, 7-Dec-2008 09:58, 10-Dec-2008 3 Motion 0 3 1 C I C C N N
Appeal Jack Merridew ban 23:58, 15-Nov-2008 09:50, 9-Dec-2008 23 Motion 0 2 0 C C N N
Clarify : SlimVirgin-Lar 12:18, 3-Dec-2008 04:29, 9-Dec-2008 6 Clarification 0 2 1 I C C N N
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 16:00, 29-Nov-2008 23:00, 3-Dec-2008 4 Case 0 5 0 C C C C N C N
Clarify : Tobias Conradi 19:49, 7-Nov-2008 17:33, 29-Nov-2008 22 Motion 0 1 0 C N N
Motion re Slim Virgin 19:46, 23-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 4 Motion 1 8 0 C C C C R C C C C N N
Amend : Bharatveer 21:42, 11-Nov-2008 13:25, 24-Nov-2008 13 Motion 0 3 1 I C C N C N
Amend : Coolcat, Davenbelle and Stereotek 17:06, 15-Nov-2008 22:11, 20-Nov-2008 5 Motion 0 2 1 I C C N N
Clarify : Everyking 3 23:16, 11-Nov-2008 12:47, 19-Nov-2008 8 Clarification 0 6 2 I I C C C C N C C N
Clarify : Lyndon LaRouche 2 10:29, 28-Oct-2008 05:25, 7-Nov-2008 10 Declined 0 1 3 I I I C N N
Amend : C68-FM-SV 22:23, 27-Oct-2008 21:55, 29-Oct-2008 2 Withdrawn 0 3 4 I I I I C N C C N
Appeal ResearchEditor block 00:07, 20-Oct-2008 16:12, 26-Oct-2008 7 Declined 0 3 2 I I C C N C N
Amend : Episodes and characters 2 06:50, 8-Oct-2008 02:23, 24-Oct-2008 16 Declined 0 2 2 I I C N C N
Amend : Martinphi-ScienceApologist 03:22, 6-Oct-2008 02:20, 24-Oct-2008 18 Declined 0 1 2 I I C N N
Clarify Steve Crossin 05:49, 22-Oct-2008 00:21, 23-Oct-2008 1 Clarification 0 2 2 I I C N C N
Clarify : Pseudoscience 03:19, 5-Oct-2008 01:48, 20-Oct-2008 15 Clarification 0 2 2 I I C C N N
Clarify editing Arbitration policy 16:09, 28-Sep-2008 23:14, 15-Oct-2008 17 Clarification 0 4 2 I I C C C N C N
Clarify : Paranormal 23:01, 3-Oct-2008 23:06, 15-Oct-2008 12 Clarification 0 3 2 I I C C C N N
Clarify : Badlydrawnjeff 04:08, 23-Sep-2008 01:38, 5-Oct-2008 12 Clarification 0 3 2 I I C C C N N
Clarify : Episodes and characters 2 15:49, 16-Sep-2008 01:35, 5-Oct-2008 18 Clarification 0 2 2 I I C C N N
Clarify topic bans 16:39, 23-Sep-2008 14:54, 27-Sep-2008 4 Clarification 0 5 2 I I C C C N C C N
Clarify : Homeopathy 00:00, 23-Sep-2008 02:26, 27-Sep-2008 4 Clarification 0 3 2 I I C C N C N
Clarify : John Buscema 00:41, 19-Sep-2008 03:05, 23-Sep-2008 4 Clarification 0 4 3 I I C C C C N I
Amend : Privatemusings 01:22, 13-Sep-2008 23:05, 21-Sep-2008 9 Clarification 0 5 3 I I C C C N C C I
Clarify RFA options for Coffee, PeterSymonds 02:18, 31-Aug-2008 21:45, 1-Sep-2008 2 Motion 0 6 2 I C C C C N C C I
Clarify Steve Crossin et al. 18:10, 23-Aug-2008 00:10, 31-Aug-2008 7 Clarification 0 5 1 C C C C C N I
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 18:40, 21-Aug-2008 21:45, 30-Aug-2008 9 Declined 0 7 2 I C C C C C C N C I
Clarify : Footnoted quotes 14:14, 8-Aug-2008 10:23, 29-Aug-2008 21 Clarification 0 3 2 I C C C N I
Amend : Privatemusings 02:56, 7-Aug-2008 23:56, 17-Aug-2008 11 Motion 0 6 1 C C C C C C I
Clarify : John_Buscema 21:43, 28-Jul-2008 20:35, 11-Aug-2008 14 Clarification 0 2 1 C N C I
Clarify : Lyndon LaRouche 2 03:08, 25-Jul-2008 13:39, 4-Aug-2008 10 Clarification 0 3 1 C C N C I
Clarify : Homeopathy 03:58, 17-Jul-2008 11:42, 31-Jul-2008 14 Clarification 0 1 1 C N I
Amend : Digwuren 22:43, 23-May-2008 13:47, 28-Jul-2008 66 Motion 0 2 1 C C N I
Amend : Pseudoscience, Martinphi-ScienceApologist 12:46, 2-May-2008 13:46, 28-Jul-2008 87 Motion 0 2 1 C C N I
Amend : Lapsed Pacifist 12:35, 14-Jul-2008 23:58, 24-Jul-2008 10 Declined 0 5 1 C C N C C C I
Clarify : Matthew Hoffman 02:53, 13-Jul-2008 13:07, 19-Jul-2008 6 Clarification 0 6 1 C C C C N C C I
Clarify : Franco-Mongol alliance 18:13, 3-Jul-2008 12:38, 19-Jul-2008 16 Clarification 0 6 1 C C C N C C C I
Request recusal 11:12, 4-Jul-2008 02:49, 7-Jul-2008 3 Declined 0 5 2 C I C C C N C I
Appeal page ban 20:53, 18-Jun-2008 02:47, 7-Jul-2008 18 Declined 0 3 2 I C C N C I
Clarify scope 12:47, 18-Jun-2008 02:42, 7-Jul-2008 19 Clarification 0 3 2 I C C C N I
Clarify : Orangemarlin 20:54, 27-Jun-2008 16:45, 29-Jun-2008 2 Clarification 0 1 3 C I I N I
Clarify Kirill announcement 02:06, 28-Jun-2008 16:40, 29-Jun-2008 2 Withdrawn 0 0 3 I I N I
Amend : Privatemusings 03:48, 11-Jun-2008 02:06, 27-Jun-2008 16 Declined 0 3 3 I I C C N I C
Injunction and restoration 19:49, 10-Jun-2008 00:58, 22-Jun-2008 11 Declined 0 0 3 I I N I
Clarify Wikipedia:General sanctions 17:30, 17-Jun-2008 18:51, 19-Jun-2008 2 Withdrawn 0 0 3 I I N I
Amend : SevenOfDiamonds 22:53, 28-May-2008 21:57, 20-Jun-2008 23 Declined 0 5 2 C I C I C N C C
Amend : Martinphi-ScienceApologist 12:48, 4-May-2008 01:09, 15-Jun-2008 42 Declined 0 2 3 I I C N I C
Clarify : Episodes and characters 2 21:30, 27-Apr-2008 01:16, 15-Jun-2008 48 Clarification 0 2 3 I C I C N I
Clarify : Episodes and characters 2 10:46, 24-Apr-2008 01:16, 15-Jun-2008 52 Clarification 0 2 3 I I C N I C
Clarify : IRC 16:40, 26-Mar-2008 10:05, 27-May-2008 62 Clarification 0 5 0 C C C C C
Amend : Coolcat, Davenbelle and Stereotek 23:48, 3-May-2008 10:03, 27-May-2008 23 Declined 0 1 0 C N
Amend : Everyking 3 18:22, 24-May-2008 13:31, 26-May-2008 2 Declined 0 3 1 I C C N C
Amend : September 11 conspiracy theories 01:18, 18-May-2008 14:16, 18-May-2008 1 Declined 0 2 2 I I C N C
Clarify : MONGO 14:48, 14-May-2008 14:14, 18-May-2008 4 Clarification 0 3 2 I I C C C N
Clarify : Commodore Sloat-Biophys 01:05, 14-May-2008 14:09, 18-May-2008 5 Clarification 0 1 2 I I C N
Amend : IRC 13:23, 26-Apr-2008 10:06, 15-May-2008 19 Declined 0 4 0 C C C C
Clarify : September 11 conspiracy theories 08:53, 27-Apr-2008 01:08, 15-May-2008 18 Clarification 0 3 0 C N C C
Appeal Thomas Basboll topic ban 07:40, 21-Apr-2008 00:59, 15-May-2008 24 Declined 0 1 0 C N
Appeal Benjiboi topic ban 13:01, 21-Apr-2008 00:56, 15-May-2008 23 Declined 0 1 0 C N
Clarify : Ebionites 21:57, 2-May-2008 01:39, 6-May-2008 3 Clarification 0 4 0 C C C N C
Amend : Privatemusings 18:18, 16-Apr-2008 22:43, 30-Apr-2008 14 Declined 0 5 0 C C C C C
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 11:28, 30-Mar-2008 23:20, 27-Apr-2008 28 Motion 0 4 0 C C C C
Amend : Armenia-Azerbaijan 2 09:44, 23-Mar-2008 00:55, 23-Apr-2008 31 Declined 0 2 1 I C C
Amend : Konstable 08:48, 14-Apr-2008 07:30, 20-Apr-2008 6 Withdrawn 0 0 1 I
Amend : Sathya Sai Baba 2 21:23, 21-Mar-2008 02:45, 12-Apr-2008 21 Motion 0 3 1 C I C C
Amend : Ferrylodge 18:55, 2-Mar-2008 09:54, 8-Apr-2008 37 Declined 0 4 1 I C C C C
Appeal Child Psychology 18:22, 1-Apr-2008 04:03, 8-Apr-2008 6 Declined 0 1 1 I C
Amend : Coolcat, Davenbelle and Stereotek 12:07, 21-Mar-2008 14:47, 5-Apr-2008 15 Declined 0 4 1 I C C C C
Clarify : Privatemusings 19:42, 4-Apr-2008 14:35, 5-Apr-2008 1 Clarification 0 3 1 I C C C
Amend : Bluemarine 22:50, 21-Mar-2008 17:28, 26-Mar-2008 5 Withdrawn 0 2 2 I C C I
Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 09:58, 18-Mar-2008 05:51, 24-Mar-2008 6 Withdrawn 0 5 2 I C C C C I C
Amend : Everyking 3 01:24, 23-Feb-2008 00:38, 24-Mar-2008 30 Declined 0 6 1 I C C C C C C
Clarify : Mantanmoreland 13:43, 13-Mar-2008 14:39, 22-Mar-2008 9 Clarification 0 3 1 I C C C
Clarify : MONGO 16:08, 8-Mar-2008 14:36, 22-Mar-2008 14 Motion 0 4 0 C C C C
Clarify : Digwuren 23:21, 8-Feb-2008 14:28, 22-Mar-2008 43 Clarification 1 3 0 R C C C
Clarify : Macedonia 20:22, 20-Feb-2008 04:15, 2-Mar-2008 10 Clarification 0 4 1 C C I C C
Amend : Ferrylodge 21:52, 21-Feb-2008 04:10, 2-Mar-2008 9 Declined 0 2 1 C I C
Appeal Octavian history 12:27, 19-Feb-2008 04:01, 2-Mar-2008 12 Declined 0 2 1 C I C
Amend : Free Republic 21:33, 10-Feb-2008 16:04, 22-Feb-2008 12 Motion 0 1 0 C
Amend : Everyking 3 06:11, 1-Feb-2008 15:59, 22-Feb-2008 21 Motion 0 3 0 C C C
Amend : DreamGuy 00:00, 4-Feb-2008 17:54, 20-Feb-2008 17 Motion 0 2 0 C C
Amend : Bluemarine 17:48, 7-Feb-2008 03:28, 15-Feb-2008 7 Declined 0 1 0 C
Amend : Martinphi-ScienceApologist 23:40, 20-Jan-2008 21:10, 4-Feb-2008 15 Declined 0 1 3 I I C I
Clarify : Pseudoscience 12:54, 24-Jan-2008 19:32, 29-Jan-2008 5 Removed 0 0 4 I I I I
Amend : Palestine-Israel articles 17:39, 22-Jan-2008 19:32, 29-Jan-2008 7 Declined 0 2 4 I I C I C I
Amend : Matthew Hoffman 21:30, 20-Jan-2008 13:08, 27-Jan-2008 7 Declined 0 1 4 I I I C I
Appeal : Digwuren 20:35, 18-Jan-2008 13:06, 27-Jan-2008 9 Declined 0 1 4 I I I C I
Amend : COFS 07:03, 15-Jan-2008 13:05, 27-Jan-2008 12 Declined 0 3 4 I I C I C C I
Amend : Free Republic 20:27, 13-Jan-2008 23:33, 21-Jan-2008 8 Declined 0 1 3 I I C I
Amend : Privatemusings 00:40, 14-Jan-2008 02:43, 19-Jan-2008 5 Declined 0 1 3 I I C I
Clarify : Ferrylodge 19:34, 11-Jan-2008 21:48, 15-Jan-2008 4 Clarification 0 0 3 I I I
Clarify : John Buscema 16:07, 10-Jan-2008 21:47, 15-Jan-2008 5 Clarification 0 1 1 I C
Clarify : Digwuren 07:54, 10-Jan-2008 04:26, 11-Jan-2008 1 Withdrawn 0 0 2 I I
Amend : DreamGuy 2 01:45, 9-Jan-2008 04:07, 11-Jan-2008 2 Declined 0 1 1 I C
Appeal : Everyking 3 21:13, 1-Jan-2008 03:35, 11-Jan-2008 9 Declined 0 2 1 I C C
Clarify : Asgardian-Tenebrae 21:56, 6-Jan-2008 03:29, 11-Jan-2008 4 Clarification 0 1 1 I C
Amend : Armenia-Azerbaijan 2 18:05, 6-Jan-2008 03:27, 11-Jan-2008 4 Declined 0 0 1 I
Enforcement : Brahma Kumaris 13:27, 26-Dec-2007 20:01, 10-Jan-2008 15 Declined 0 1 1 I C
Amend : Digwuren 18:40, 13-Dec-2007 19:59, 10-Jan-2008 28 Declined 0 1 1 I C
Clarify : Episodes and characters 17:05, 28-Dec-2007 21:38, 1-Jan-2008 4 Removed 0 0 3 I I I

Arb activity[edit]

The following table contains three sections, the first covering case requests, the second other requests and the third all requests. The column headings have the following meanings:

  • ER (eligible requests): Indicates the beginning of a new section and gives the total number respectively, of case requests, other requests, or all requests, for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of requests for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as inactive/away at the time of the request's closing, and did not act on the request (i.e. did not recuse. accept, decline or comment) (count of "I"s); as a percentage of ER.
  • R (recused): The total number of requests for which this arb recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (ERI).
  • V (voted): The total number of case requests this arb voted to accept or decline (count of "A"s or "D"s); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of requests for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as active at the time of the request's closing, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).
  • A (accept): The total number of case requests this arb voted to accept (count of "A"s); as a percentage of V.
  • D (decline): The total number of case requests this arb voted to decline (count of "D"s); as a percentage of V.
  • C (comment): The total number of other requests this arb commented on (count of "C"s); as a percentage of (ER − (I + R)).
Arb activity (2008) — requests
Arb ER I % R % V % DNA % A % D % ER I % R % C % DNA % ER I % R % DNA %
Charles Matthews 152 51 34% 3 3% 30 31% 66 67% 9 30% 21 70% 103 32 31% 0 0% 6 8% 65 92% 255 83 33% 3 2% 131 76%
Deskana 152 67 44% 1 1% 16 19% 68 81% 3 19% 13 81% 103 44 43% 1 2% 4 7% 54 92% 255 111 44% 2 1% 122 85%
FayssalF 152 18 12% 1 1% 53 40% 74 56% 18 34% 35 66% 103 12 12% 0 0% 20 22% 71 78% 255 30 12% 1 0% 145 64%
FloNight 152 10 7% 1 1% 120 85% 16 11% 35 29% 85 71% 103 13 13% 0 0% 40 44% 50 56% 255 23 9% 1 0% 66 28%
FT2 152 9 6% 2 1% 35 25% 99 70% 11 31% 24 69% 103 7 7% 1 1% 27 28% 68 71% 255 16 6% 3 1% 167 70%
Jdforrester 152 4 3% 0 0% 34 23% 111 75% 8 24% 26 76% 103 3 3% 0 0% 18 18% 82 82% 255 7 3% 0 0% 193 78%
Jpgordon 152 0 0% 5 3% 85 58% 58 39% 14 16% 71 84% 103 0 0% 0 0% 16 16% 87 84% 255 0 0% 5 2% 145 57%
Kirill Lokshin 152 0 0% 3 2% 73 49% 76 51% 24 33% 49 67% 103 0 0% 0 0% 21 20% 82 80% 255 0 0% 3 1% 158 62%
Morven 152 10 7% 0 0% 29 20% 110 77% 11 38% 18 62% 103 6 6% 0 0% 17 18% 80 82% 255 16 6% 0 0% 190 79%
Newyorkbrad 108 5 5% 6 6% 76 78% 13 13% 15 20% 61 80% 74 2 3% 0 0% 43 60% 29 40% 182 7 4% 6 3% 42 24%
Paul August 120 23 19% 0 0% 43 44% 51 53% 3 7% 40 93% 72 11 15% 0 0% 7 11% 54 89% 192 34 18% 0 0% 105 66%
Sam Blacketer 152 0 0% 2 1% 123 82% 23 15% 32 26% 91 74% 103 0 0% 0 0% 34 33% 69 67% 255 0 0% 2 1% 92 36%
Stephen Bain 152 13 9% 2 1% 56 41% 76 55% 24 43% 32 57% 103 9 9% 0 0% 21 22% 73 78% 255 22 9% 2 1% 149 64%
UninvitedCompany 133 28 21% 1 1% 11 11% 93 89% 4 36% 7 64% 78 18 23% 0 0% 0 0% 60 100% 211 46 22% 1 1% 153 93%
YellowMonkey 152 7 5% 0 0% 9 6% 135 93% 2 22% 7 78% 103 1 1% 0 0% 1 1% 101 99% 255 8 3% 0 0% 236 96%
Case requests Clarifications and other requests All requests

Motions[edit]

  • Legend: S=Support, O=Oppose, A=Abstain, Ac=Active arbs, R=Recuse, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible, Offered = the arb who posted the motion.
  • Motions: 56; average duration: 11.7 days; passed: 27 (48%); failed: 29 (52%).
Motions involving 2008 arbs only
Motion Per Request Opened Closed Days Disp S O Ab Ac R I M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg Kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Offered
1) Moreschi is restricted Moreschi 16:15, 17-Dec-2008 14:58, 20-Dec-2008 3 Failed 4 3 1 10 2 1 5 R O S I O R O S A N S S N Ste
1.1) Moreschi is admonished Moreschi 18:36, 17-Dec-2008 14:58, 20-Dec-2008 3 Failed 1 4 1 10 2 1 5 R O S I R O O A N O N Flo
1.2) The administrative privileges Moreschi 20:46, 17-Dec-2008 14:58, 20-Dec-2008 3 Failed 1 5 0 10 2 1 6 R O O I R O O O N S N Sam
1.3) Based upon the events Moreschi 21:08, 17-Dec-2008 14:58, 20-Dec-2008 3 Passed 6 1 0 10 2 1 6 R S S I R S S S N O S N New
1) Any ban, block, or Clarify "Peter Damian" 23:07, 7-Dec-2008 23:58, 17-Dec-2008 10 Failed 1 5 0 12 0 1 7 O I O O S N O O N New
1.1) The editing restrictions Clarify "Peter Damian" 01:49, 9-Dec-2008 23:58, 17-Dec-2008 9 Passed 7 3 0 12 0 1 7 O S S I S O S S N O S N S Kir
Alastair Haines Amend : Alastair Haines 21:01, 23-Nov-2008 23:46, 17-Dec-2008 24 Failed 1 5 0 12 0 1 7 I O S O N O O N O Kir
Abtract Amend : Alastair Haines 23:26, 30-Nov-2008 23:46, 17-Dec-2008 17 Passed 8 0 0 12 0 1 7 S I S S S S N S S N S New
1) All pages of Amend : Matthew Hoffman 21:01, 15-Nov-2008 06:22, 16-Dec-2008 30 Failed 2 5 2 12 1 0 6 R S O O S O A N O A N O Kir
1.1) All pages of Amend : Matthew Hoffman 05:12, 17-Nov-2008 06:22, 16-Dec-2008 29 Failed 3 3 2 11 1 1 5 R O I O S S A N S A N O Kir
1.2) All pages of Amend : Matthew Hoffman 20:38, 17-Nov-2008 06:22, 16-Dec-2008 28 Failed 2 4 2 11 1 1 5 R S I O S O A N O A N O Flo
1.3) All pages of Amend : Matthew Hoffman 05:26, 20-Nov-2008 06:22, 16-Dec-2008 26 Passed 6 3 1 12 1 0 6 R S O S S S O S N S A N O New
This committee's decision Amend : Bluemarine 22:54, 7-Dec-2008 09:58, 10-Dec-2008 2 Passed 7 0 0 13 0 0 7 S S S S S S N S N New
1) After reviewing Appeal "Jack Merridew ban" 23:58, 15-Nov-2008 09:50, 9-Dec-2008 23 Passed 8 0 0 13 0 0 7 S S S S S S N S S N Flo
Motion re Tobias Conradi Clarify : Tobias Conradi 19:49, 7-Nov-2008 17:33, 29-Nov-2008 22 Failed 2 4 2 12 0 1 6 S I O O S O A N O A N Cha
Alternative re Tobias Conradi Clarify : Tobias Conradi 07:40, 16-Nov-2008 17:33, 29-Nov-2008 13 Passed 6 0 2 12 0 1 6 S I A S S S S A N S N FT2
1) Restriction on Motion re Slim Virgin 00:11, 25-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 3 Passed 7 1 0 12 1 0 7 S S S R S S S O N S N Kir
1A) Guidelines for Motion re Slim Virgin 15:35, 25-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 2 Failed 2 5 0 12 1 0 7 O O O R O O S N S N New
2) SlimVirgin restricted Motion re Slim Virgin 00:11, 25-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 3 Failed 4 4 0 12 1 0 7 S O O R O S S S N O N Kir
2A) SlimVirgin restricted Motion re Slim Virgin 15:41, 25-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 2 Failed 0 0 0 12 1 0 7 R N N New
3) SlimVirgin desysopped Motion re Slim Virgin 00:11, 25-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 3 Failed 3 5 0 12 1 0 7 S S O R O S O O N O N Kir
3A) SlimVirgin desysopped Motion re Slim Virgin 09:31, 26-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 1 Passed 6 1 1 12 1 0 6 S S S R O S S A N S N Des
4) Restriction on Motion re Slim Virgin 00:11, 25-Nov-2008 18:25, 27-Nov-2008 3 Passed 7 0 1 12 0 1 6 S S S I S S S A N S N Kir
1) Bharatveer is banned Amend : Bharatveer 01:02, 12-Nov-2008 13:25, 24-Nov-2008 13 Passed 6 0 0 11 0 2 6 I S I S S S S N S N Kir
1.1) Bharatveer is subject Amend : Bharatveer 01:02, 12-Nov-2008 13:25, 24-Nov-2008 13 Failed* 6 0 0 11 0 2 6 I S I S S S S N S N Kir
1.2) Based upon Amend : Bharatveer 01:02, 12-Nov-2008 13:25, 24-Nov-2008 13 Failed* 6 0 0 11 0 2 6 I S I S S S S N S N New
Motion to lift Coolcat Amend : Coolcat, Davenbelle and Stereotek 17:06, 15-Nov-2008 22:11, 20-Nov-2008 5 Passed 6 0 1 12 0 1 6 S I S A S S N S S N Flo
On September 17, Unapproved admin bots 13:48, 23-Sep-2008 20:44, 25-Sep-2008 2 Failed* 6 3 1 11 0 2 6 I I O S A S S S O S N O S N New
Alternate motion Unapproved admin bots 20:09, 23-Sep-2008 20:44, 25-Sep-2008 2 Passed 7 2 1 11 0 2 6 I I A S S S S O S S N S O N New
Motion in E104421-Tajik 00:11, 12-Sep-2008 14:49, 13-Sep-2008 2 Passed 8 0 0 11 0 3 6 I I S S S S S N S S I S Ste
In lieu of opening Georgewilliamherbert 00:36, 3-Sep-2008 03:23, 12-Sep-2008 9 Failed 2 3 1 11 0 3 6 I I A O S O S N O I New
User:Coffee and Clarify RFA options for Coffee, PeterSymonds 22:13, 31-Aug-2008 21:45, 1-Sep-2008 1 Passed 7 0 0 12 0 2 7 I S S S S S N S S I Jpg
Remedy 2 Amend : Privatemusings 21:17, 12-Aug-2008 23:56, 17-Aug-2008 5 Passed 8 0 0 14 0 1 8 S S S S S S S S I Jpg
Discretionary sanctions et al. Amend : Digwuren 01:18, 27-Jun-2008 13:47, 28-Jul-2008 32 Passed 6 1 1 13 0 1 7 S S S S S N A S O I Kir
Discretionary sanctions et al. Amend : Pseudoscience, Martinphi-ScienceApologist 01:19, 27-Jun-2008 13:46, 28-Jul-2008 32 Passed 7 2 0 13 0 1 7 S S S S S S N O S O I Kir
1) CSCWEM is directed 17:51, 18-Jul-2008 23:56, 18-Jul-2008 0 Failed 0 8 0 13 0 1 7 O O O O O O N O O I FT2
2) CSCWEM desysopped 17:51, 18-Jul-2008 23:56, 18-Jul-2008 0 Passed 8 0 0 13 0 1 7 S S S S S S N S S I FT2
Kww restricted Clarify : Episodes and characters 2 20:05, 18-May-2008 01:16, 15-Jun-2008 27 Failed 2 5 0 15 0 0 8 O S O S O O O Kir
TTN restricted Clarify : Episodes and characters 2 20:05, 18-May-2008 01:16, 15-Jun-2008 27 Failed 4 3 0 15 0 0 8 O S O S S O S Kir
Special enforcement Clarify : IRC 02:49, 17-Apr-2008 10:05, 27-May-2008 40 Failed 3 0 0 15 0 0 8 S S S Kir
PHG is required Amend : Franco-Mongol alliance 20:00, 16-Apr-2008 23:20, 27-Apr-2008 11 Passed 8 0 0 15 0 0 8 S S S S S S S S Flo
Alternative: Remedy 1.1 of Amend : Sathya Sai Baba 2 16:24, 1-Apr-2008 02:45, 12-Apr-2008 10 Passed 7 0 0 13 0 2 7 I S S S S S S I S New
Original: Remedy 1.1 of Amend : Sathya Sai Baba 2 22:38, 30-Mar-2008 02:45, 12-Apr-2008 12 Failed 4 2 0 13 0 2 7 S I S O O S I S Sam
1 - It is not prohibited Clarify : Mongo 02:31, 9-Mar-2008 14:36, 22-Mar-2008 14 Passed 9 0 2 14 0 1 7 S I S S S S S S A S S A New
2 - Linking if article recreated Clarify : Mongo 14:32, 9-Mar-2008 14:36, 22-Mar-2008 13 Failed 1 7 1 14 0 1 7 O I O O S O O O A O FT2
3 - Attack links Clarify : Mongo 04:03, 9-Mar-2008 14:36, 22-Mar-2008 13 Failed 1 7 1 14 0 1 7 O I O A S O O O O O FT2
4 - Sourcing from websites Clarify : Mongo 04:03, 9-Mar-2008 14:36, 22-Mar-2008 13 Failed 1 8 1 14 0 1 7 O I O A S O O O O O O FT2
5 - Amendment to past cases Clarify : Mongo 04:03, 9-Mar-2008 14:36, 22-Mar-2008 13 Failed 1 7 1 14 0 1 7 O I O O S O O A O O FT2
The general restriction Clarify : Digwuren 13:55, 21-Feb-2008 14:28, 22-Mar-2008 30 Failed 3 0 0 14 0 1 8 I S S S Kir
In light of Amend : Free Republic 23:50, 14-Feb-2008 16:04, 22-Feb-2008 8 Passed 8 0 0 14 1 0 8 S S S R S S S S S New
1) Any remaining restrictions Amend : Everyking 3 23:30, 14-Feb-2008 15:59, 22-Feb-2008 8 Failed* 8 2 1 15 0 0 8 A S S S O S S S S O S New
2) Remedy 2 of Amend : Everyking 3 00:48, 15-Feb-2008 15:59, 22-Feb-2008 8 Passed 12 0 0 15 0 0 8 S S S S S S S S S S S S Jpg
Add an additional Amend : DreamGuy 23:30, 14-Feb-2008 17:54, 20-Feb-2008 6 Passed 9 0 0 15 0 0 8 S S S S S S S S S FT2
Discretionary sanctions in Armenia-Azerbaijan #1 17:48, 12-Jan-2008 02:31, 19-Jan-2008 6 Failed* 7 1 0 13 0 2 7 I I S S O S S S S S Kir
Discretionary sanctions in Armenia-Azerbaijan #2 03:53, 17-Jan-2008 02:31, 19-Jan-2008 2 Passed 8 0 0 13 0 2 7 I I S S S S S S S S FT2
Liancourt Rocks article probation 22:53, 6-Jan-2008 00:53, 8-Jan-2008 1 Passed 8 0 0 14 0 1 8 I S S S S S S S S Kir
  • Failed*: Although receiving enough supports to pass, the motion failed in favor of an alternative motion.

Arb activity[edit]

The column headings, in table below, have the following meanings:

  • EM (eligible motions): The total number of motions for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of motions for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as inactive/away at the time of the motion's closing, and did not act on the motion (i.e. did not recuse. support, oppose or abstain) (count of "I"s); as a percentage of EM.
  • R (recused): The total number of motions for which this arb recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EMI).
  • V (voted): The total number of motions this arb voted to support or oppose (count of "S"s or "O"s); as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • A (abstained): The total number of motions for which this arb abstained (count of "A"s), as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of motions for which this arb was listed at Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee as active at the time of the motion's closing, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (EM − (I + R)).
  • S (supported): The total number of motions this arb supported (count of "S"s); as a percentage of V.
  • O (opposed): The total number of motions this arb opposed (count of "O"s); as a percentage of V.
  • Offered: The total number of motions which this arb offered; as a percentage of the total number of motions.
Arb activity (2008) — motions
Arb EM I % R % V % A % DNA % S % O % Offered %
Charles Matthews 56 7 13% 8 16% 17 41% 1 2% 23 56% 11 65% 6 35% 1 2%
Deskana 56 15 27% 0 0% 18 44% 0 0% 23 56% 12 67% 6 33% 1 2%
FayssalF 56 6 11% 0 0% 19 38% 2 4% 29 58% 11 58% 8 42% 0 0%
FloNight 56 0 0% 0 0% 49 88% 3 5% 4 7% 38 78% 11 22% 5 9%
FT2 56 14 25% 6 14% 22 61% 2 6% 12 33% 17 77% 5 23% 9 16%
Jdforrester 56 0 0% 0 0% 27 48% 0 0% 29 52% 14 52% 13 48% 0 0%
Jpgordon 56 0 0% 5 9% 33 65% 0 0% 18 35% 26 79% 7 21% 3 5%
Kirill Lokshin 56 0 0% 0 0% 51 91% 0 0% 5 9% 39 76% 12 24% 18 32%
Morven 56 0 0% 0 0% 27 48% 0 0% 29 52% 17 63% 10 37% 0 0%
Newyorkbrad 52 0 0% 0 0% 36 69% 11 21% 5 10% 29 81% 7 19% 15 27%
Paul August 24 2 8% 0 0% 13 59% 1 5% 8 36% 8 62% 5 38% 0 0%
Sam Blacketer 56 0 0% 0 0% 54 96% 1 2% 1 2% 37 69% 17 31% 2 4%
Stephen Bain 56 0 0% 0 0% 18 32% 5 9% 33 59% 13 72% 5 28% 2 4%
UninvitedCompany 27 8 30% 0 0% 9 47% 1 5% 9 47% 4 44% 5 56% 0 0%
YellowMonkey 56 0 0% 0 0% 10 18% 0 0% 46 82% 5 50% 5 50% 0 0%

Cases[edit]

  • Legend: Ac=Active, R=Recused, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible, Drafter = the poster of the first draft on the case's "Proposed decision" page.
  • Publicly heard cases: 38; average duration: 39 days; decided: 35 (92%); dismissed: 3 (8%).

Involving 2008 arbs only[edit]

Publicly heard cases involving 2008 arbs only
Case Opened Closed Days Disp Ac R I M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg Kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Drafter
Eastern European disputes 29-Aug-2008 23-Dec-2008 115 Decided 10 0 3 6 I I I N N Kir
Cold fusion 14-Nov-2008 15-Dec-2008 31 Decided 11 0 2 6 I I N N Ste
Kuban kazak 5-Nov-2008 5-Dec-2008 30 Decided 10 0 3 6 I I I N N Kir
SlimVirgin-Lar 23-Jul-2008 30-Oct-2008 99 Decided 11 1 2 6 I I R N Kir
Abtract-Collectonian 15-Oct-2008 29-Oct-2008 14 Decided 11 0 2 6 I I N N New
Sarah Palin protection wheel war 5-Sep-2008 20-Oct-2008 45 Decided 11 0 2 6 I I N N New
C68-FM-SV 16-May-2008 24-Sep-2008 131 Decided 9 2 3 5 I I R R N I New
Alastair Haines 8-Aug-2008 11-Sep-2008 34 Decided 11 0 3 6 I I N I Kir
Geogre-William M. Connolley 3-Jul-2008 22-Aug-2008 50 Decided 12 1 2 7 I R I Ste
Yorkshirian 28-Jun-2008 14-Jul-2008 16 Decided 10 0 4 6 I I N I I Kir
Giovanni33 4-May-2008 6-Jul-2008 63 Decided 11 1 2 6 R I N I Kir
Homeopathy 19-Apr-2008 30-Jun-2008 72 Decided 12 0 2 7 I N I Kir
Footnoted quotes 4-May-2008 16-Jun-2008 43 Decided 11 0 3 6 I I N I Kir
CAMERA lobbying 29-Apr-2008 28-May-2008 29 Decided 12 0 2 7 I N I Kir
Tango 19-Apr-2008 16-May-2008 27 Decided 12 1 2 7 I I R Ste
Prem Rawat 18-Mar-2008 12-May-2008 55 Decided 13 1 1 7 R I Ste
Strider12 1-Apr-2008 21-Apr-2008 20 Decided 13 0 2 7 I I Kir
Betacommand 2 16-Mar-2008 13-Apr-2008 28 Decided 13 1 1 7 I R Uni
International Churches of Christ 28-Mar-2008 12-Apr-2008 15 Decided 13 0 2 7 I I New
September 11 conspiracy theories 19-Mar-2008 8-Apr-2008 20 Decided 11 2 2 6 I R R I Kir
Highways 2 2-Jan-2008 7-Apr-2008 96 Decided 12 1 2 7 I I R Flo
Franco-Mongol alliance 5-Feb-2008 14-Mar-2008 38 Decided 12 1 2 7 I I R New
Mantanmoreland 14-Feb-2008 13-Mar-2008 28 Decided 13 1 1 7 I R New
Ehud Lesar 30-Jan-2008 12-Mar-2008 42 Decided 14 0 1 8 I Sam
Episodes and characters 2 19-Jan-2008 10-Mar-2008 51 Decided 12 0 3 7 I I I Kir
New World Translation 22-Feb-2008 1-Mar-2008 8 Dismissed 13 1 1 7 I R
Waterboarding 13-Jan-2008 15-Feb-2008 33 Decided 11 1 3 6 I I R I Kir
Bluemarine 7-Jan-2008 1-Feb-2008 25 Decided 12 0 3 7 I I I Sam
Kingofmann 18-Jan-2008 21-Jan-2008 3 Dismissed 12 0 3 7 I I I
Palestine-Israel articles 10-Jan-2008 19-Jan-2008 9 Decided 13 0 2 7 I I Kir
R. fiend 11-Jan-2008 14-Jan-2008 3 Dismissed 13 0 2 7 I I
Zeraeph 1-Jan-2008 14-Jan-2008 13 Decided 11 2 2 6 I R R I Kir
John Gohde 2 2-Jan-2008 12-Jan-2008 10 Decided 14 0 1 8 I Kir
Jim62sch 2-Jan-2008 9-Jan-2008 7 Decided 14 0 1 8 I New

Involving 2008 and departing 2007 arbs[edit]

Publicly heard cases Involving 2008 and departing 2007 arbs
Case Opened Closed Days Ac R I M Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg Kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel Drafter
Matthew Hoffman 2-Dec-2007 13-Feb-2008 72 11 1 5 6 R N N I I I I N I N Uni
IRC 26-Dec-2007 9-Feb-2008 45 12 2 6 7 I N I R I I I I R Uni
Dbachmann 3-Dec-2007 14-Jan-2008 42 13 0 5 7 I N N I I I N I Kir
John Buscema 5-Dec-2007 8-Jan-2008 34 12 0 5 7 I N N I N I I N I New

Arb activity[edit]

Legend[edit]

The column headings, in the two tables below, have the following meanings:

  • EC (eligible cases): The total number of cases for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • Inactive: The total number of cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as inactive/away (count of empty cells); as a percentage of EC.
  • Recused: The total number of cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (ECInactive).
  • Drafted: The total number of cases for which this arb posted the first draft of the case's "Proposed decision" page; as a percentage of the total number of cases decided.

Arb activity (2008)[edit]

Arb activity (2008) — cases
Arb EC Inactive % Recused % Drafted %
Charles Matthews 38 20 53% 2 11% 0 0%
Deskana 35 24 69% 1 9% 0 0%
FayssalF 34 8 24% 2 8% 0 0%
FloNight 38 1 3% 3 8% 1 3%
FT2 37 2 5% 0 0% 0 0%
Jdforrester 38 1 3% 1 3% 0 0%
Jpgordon 38 1 3% 2 5% 0 0%
Kirill Lokshin 38 0 0% 3 8% 17 49%
Morven 38 3 8% 0 0% 0 0%
Newyorkbrad 33 1 3% 2 6% 8 23%
Paul August 31 4 13% 0 0% 0 0%
Sam Blacketer 35 0 0% 1 3% 2 6%
Stephen Bain 37 2 5% 1 3% 4 11%
UninvitedCompany 32 8 25% 1 4% 3 9%
YellowMonkey 38 0 0% 1 3% 0 0%

Arb activity (departing 2007)[edit]

Arb activity (departing 2007) — cases
Arb EC Inactive % Recused % Drafted %
Flcelloguy 4 4 0% 0 0 0%
Fred Bauder 4 0 0% 0 0% 0 0%
Mackensen 4 2 50% 0 0% 0 0%
Neutrality 4 4 100% 0 0 0%
Raul654 4 4 0% 0 0 0%
SimonP 4 4 100% 0 0 0%

Proposals[edit]

  • Legend: S=Support, O=Oppose, A=Abstain, Ac=Active, R=Recused, I=Inactive/away, M=Majority, N=Not eligible. An "S1" indicates the first supporting vote. The numbers in the second set of arb columns give the length of time (rounded to the nearest day) between the first action (support, oppose or abstain) on this proposal and this arb's action.
  • Proposals: 841; passed: 587 (70%); failed: 254 (30%).

For cases involving 2008 arbs only[edit]

Case proposals for cases involving 2008 arbs only
Eastern European disputes - Proposals (AC=10, R=0, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N S 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32 18
Conduct of editors P2 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N S 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32 18
Wikipedia editorial process P3 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N S 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32 18
Common sense P4 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N S 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32 18
Content disputes P5 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32
Editorial disputes and "The Wrong Version" P6 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32
Casting aspersions P7 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N S 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32 18
Biographies of living persons P8 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N S 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32 18
Administrators P9 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S I S1 S S N S S N S 8 0 1 7 0 10 1 5 32 18
Conduct on Arbitration pages P10 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S S S1 N S S N S 7 0 5 0 9 0 3 31 17
Endemic conflict F1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Amnesty F2 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Discretionary sanctions F3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Heightened tensions F4 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Externally coordinated editing F5 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Involvement by security organs F6.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Involvement by security organs F6.2 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Arbitration enforcement F7 Passed 5 0 4 4 A I I S S I S1 A A N S A N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 21
Alden Jones F8 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 30
Alex Bakharev F9 Passed 7 0 2 5 A I I S S I S1 S A N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 18
Biophys F10 Failed 2 5 2 5 O I I S O I S1 O A N O A N O 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 32
Boodlesthecat F11.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 30
Boodlesthecat F11.2 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S I S1 S S N S N 0 7 0 10 1 5
Boodlesthecat F11.3 Passed 7 0 1 5 I I S S I S1 S A N S S N S 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 30
Deacon of Pndapetzim F12 Passed 6 3 0 6 O I I S S I S1 S O N S N O 9 0 7 0 10 17 33 22
Greg park avenue F13 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 0 7 0 10 1 5 33 30
Halibutt F14 Passed 7 0 2 5 A I I S S I S1 S A N S S N S 10 1 7 0 10 1 5 33 32
Irpen F15.1 Passed 7 2 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S O N S S N O 8 1 7 0 10 17 5 33 32
Irpen F15.2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 1 7 0 10 3 5 33 32
Irpen F15.3 Passed 6 0 2 5 I I S S I S1 S A N S S N A 1 7 0 10 3 5 33 32
Irpen F15.4 Failed* 5 1 1 5 I I S S I S1 S A N S O N 1 7 0 10 3 5 33
Koretek F16 Passed 4 0 4 4 I I S A I S1 A A N S A N S 1 7 0 10 1 5 33 33
Lokyz F17 Failed 4 4 1 5 A I I S S I S1 O O N S O N O 9 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 32
M.K F18 Passed 7 0 3 4 A I I S S I S1 S A N S A N S 10 2 7 0 10 1 5 33 35
M0RD00R F19 Passed 7 0 2 5 A I I S S I S1 S A N S S N S 10 2 7 0 10 1 5 33 35
Malik Shabazz F20 Passed 7 0 2 5 A I I S S I S1 S A N S S N S 10 2 7 0 10 1 5 33 35
Martintg F21 Passed 7 0 2 5 A I I S S I S1 S A N S S N S 10 2 7 0 10 1 5 33 35
Matthead F22 Failed 2 3 4 4 A I I S A I S1 A A N O O N O 9 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 33
Molobo F23.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 9 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 29
Molobo F23.2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 35
Novickas F24 Passed 6 0 3 4 A I I S S I S1 S A N S A N S 10 2 7 0 10 1 5 33 35
Piotrus F25.1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 29
Piotrus F25.2 Failed 3 3 3 4 S I I S O I S1 A O N A A N O 9 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 29
Piotrus F25.3 Passed 6 0 3 4 A I I S S I S1 S A N S S N A 12 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 29
Piotrus F25.4 Passed 6 1 2 5 A I I S S I S1 S A N S O N S 12 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 29
Piotrus F25.5 Passed 6 0 3 4 A I I S S I S1 S A N S S N A 12 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 29
Piotrus F25.6 Failed 1 3 5 3 A I I O O I S1 A A N A O N A 12 2 7 0 10 3 5 33 29
Poeticbent F26 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N 9 2 7 0 10 3 5 33
Relata_refero F27 Passed 7 1 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S O N S S N 9 5 7 0 10 17 5 33
Sciurinæ F28 Failed 1 7 0 6 I I O O I S1 O O N O O N O 16 7 0 10 3 5 33 35
Stor stark7 F29 Passed 4 1 3 4 A I I S S I S1 A O N A S N 9 5 7 0 10 17 5 33
Tymek F30 Passed 6 0 3 4 A I I S S I S1 S A N S A N S 10 5 7 0 10 1 5 33 33
#wikipedia-en-admins F31.1 Passed 6 0 3 4 S I I A A I S1 S S N S S N A 12 3 7 0 10 3 6 33 35
#wikipedia-en-admins F31.2 Passed 5 0 4 4 A I I A A I S1 S S N S S N A 12 3 7 0 10 3 6 33 35
#wikipedia-en-admins F31.3 Passed 4 0 5 3 A I I A A I S1 A S N S S N A 12 3 7 0 10 3 6 33 35
#wikipedia-en-admins F31.4 Passed 6 0 3 4 S I I A A I S1 S S N S S N A 12 3 7 0 10 3 6 33 35
#wikipedia-en-admins F31.5 Failed 1 3 4 4 O I I A I S1 A A N O O N A 12 3 0 10 3 6 33 35
#wikipedia-en-admins F31.6 Passed 6 0 3 4 S I I A A I S S S1 N S S N A 8 2 3 0 7 0 3 29 32
#wikipedia-en-admins F31.7 Passed 6 0 3 4 S I I A A I S S S1 N S S N A 8 2 3 0 7 0 3 29 32
Alden Jones mentored R1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N S 12 0 7 0 10 5 24 33 30
Alden Jones prohibited from reverting R1.1 Failed 0 5 0 6 I I O I O O O N N O 1 0 5 0 25
Alden Jones restricted R1.2 Passed 7 0 1 5 I I S S I S S S1 N S A N S 0 1 0 5 0 1 27 30
Biophys admonished R2 Failed 2 5 1 5 I I S O I S1 O O N O A N O 0 7 0 10 5 5 33 35
Boodlesthecat banned R3 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S I S1 S S N S S N 0 7 0 10 5 5 33
Boodlesthecat banned, mentored, restricted R3.1A Failed 4 1 0 6 I I S O I S1 N S S N 2 14 0 10 16
Deacon of Pndapetzim admonished R4 Passed 6 2 0 6 I I S S I S1 S O N S S N O 0 7 0 10 17 5 33 30
Greg park avenue banned R5 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S I S1 S S N S S N 0 7 0 10 5 5 33
Greg park avenue banned, mentored, restricted R5.1A Failed 4 2 0 6 I I S O I O S1 N S S N 2 14 13 0 7 16
Irpen restricted R6.1 Failed 5 3 0 6 I I O S I S1 S O N S S N O 6 7 0 10 5 5 33 35
Irpen restricted R6.1A Passed 8 1 0 6 S I I S S I O S S1 N S S N S 6 1 1 0 5 0 1 27 30
Irpen restricted R6.2 Passed 6 2 0 6 I I S S I S1 S O N S S N O 6 7 0 10 5 5 33 32
Irpen admonished R6.2A Failed* 6 1 0 6 I I S S I S S1 N S S N O 1 1 0 0 1 27 26
Lokyz restricted R7.1 Failed 2 6 0 6 I I S O I S1 O O N O O N O 6 7 0 10 5 5 33 35
Lokyz admonished R7.1A Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S I S S S1 N S N 1 1 0 5 0 1
Lokyz restricted R7.2 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S I S1 S S N S N 6 7 0 10 5 5
Matthead restricted R8.1 Failed 2 6 0 6 I I S O I S1 O O N O O N O 6 7 0 10 5 5 33 35
Matthead restricted R8.2 Failed 3 3 2 5 I I S S I S1 A A N O O N O 6 7 0 10 5 5 33 35
Moreschi commended R9 Failed 1 2 5 3 A I I O O I S1 A A N A A N 9 6 7 0 10 6 27 33
Piotrus urged R10 Failed* 5 0 1 5 I I S S I S1 A N S S N 6 7 0 5 5 33
Piotrus urged R10.1 Passed 8 1 0 6 S I I S S I O S S1 N S S N S 6 1 1 0 5 0 1 27 30
Piotrus reminded R11 Failed 2 5 1 5 I I S O I S1 O O N O A N O 6 7 0 10 5 5 33 32
Piotrus cautioned R11.1 Passed 7 1 1 5 S I I S S I S S A N S1 S N O 6 3 1 0 5 0 0 27 26
Piotrus admonished R12 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N 12 8 7 0 10 5 5 33
Piotrus mentored R13 Failed 2 5 0 6 I I S O I S1 O O N O N O 8 7 0 10 5 5 35
Poeticbent mentored R14 Passed 7 0 1 5 A I I S S I S1 S S N S S N 9 8 7 0 10 5 5 33
Relata_refero admonished R15 Passed 7 1 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S O N S S N 9 8 7 0 10 17 5 33
Sciurinæ admonished R16 Failed 1 6 1 5 I I O O I S1 O O N A O N O 16 7 0 10 5 5 33 35
Stor stark7 banned R17 Failed 1 6 2 5 A I I A O I S1 O O N O O N O 12 8 7 0 10 5 5 33 35
Editors reminded R18 Passed 7 0 1 5 S I I S S I A S S1 N S S N 8 3 3 0 7 0 2 29
Editors counseled R19 Passed 7 0 1 5 S I I S S I A S S1 N S S N 8 3 3 0 7 0 2 29
#wikipedia-en-admins deprecated R20.1 Failed* 3 1 5 3 S I I A A I S1 A O N A S N A 12 3 7 0 10 6 6 33 35
#wikipedia-en-admins deprecated R20.2 Failed 2 3 4 4 O I I A A I S1 A O N S O N A 12 3 7 0 10 6 6 33 35
#wikipedia-en-admins users reminded R20.3 Passed 4 0 5 3 A I I A A I S A S1 N S S N A 5 2 0 27 4 0 18 26 29
Arbitration enforcement reform R21 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N 12 0 7 0 10 3 6 33
Content dispute resolution reform R22 Failed 2 2 1 5 I I S O I S1 A N O N 0 7 0 3 33
Content dispute resolution reform R22.1 Failed 1 4 0 6 O I I O I O O S1 N N 8 3 0 7 0
Content dispute resolution reform R22.2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S I S S S1 N S S N S 1 1 0 5 0 1 27 30
Arbitration guides R23 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S S N 12 0 7 0 10 3 6 33
Case pages blanked R24 Failed 2 2 4 4 O I I S O I S1 A A N A A N 12 0 7 0 10 3 6 33
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 7 0 0 6 S I I S S I S1 S S N S N 12 3 7 0 10 4 5
Cold fusion - Proposals (AC=11, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Role of the Arbitration Committee P1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Neutral Point Of View P2 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Neutral point of view and sourcing P3 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Undue weight P4 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
No original research P5 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Weasel words P6 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Editorial process P7 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Decorum P8 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Privileged nature of mediation P9 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Encyclopedic coverage of science P10 Passed 7 1 0 6 S S I S1 I S S S N S O N 3 2 0 7 1 0 6 7
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S I S S S N S S1 N 4 4 1 9 3 2 7 0
Editing of cold fusion F2 Passed 8 0 0 6 S S I S1 I S S S N S S N 4 3 0 8 2 1 7 1
Pcarbonn F3 Passed 7 0 0 6 S S I S1 I S S S N S N 3 2 0 7 1 0 6
Restarting discussion R1.1 Failed 1 7 0 6 O O I O I O O O N O S1 N 4 4 2 9 3 2 7 0
Restarting discussion R1.2 Failed 1 7 0 6 O O I O I O O O N O S1 N 4 4 2 9 3 2 7 0
No further action R2 Failed 1 5 2 5 A O I O I O A O N O S1 N 4 4 2 9 3 2 7 0
Pcarbonn topic-banned R3 Passed 7 1 0 6 S S I S1 I S S S N S O N 3 2 0 7 1 0 6 7
Pcarbonn restricted R3.1 Failed 1 6 0 6 O O I O I O O S1 N O N 2 2 0 7 1 0 5
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 7 0 0 6 S S I S I S S N S S1 N 4 4 2 9 2 7 0
Kuban kazak - Proposals (AC=10, R=0, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S I S1 S S N S S N S 1 0 0 10 2 4 18 16
Conduct of editors P2 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S I S1 S S N S S N S 1 0 0 10 2 4 18 16
Use of languages other than English P3 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S I S1 S S N S S N S 1 0 0 10 2 4 18 16
User pages P4 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S I S1 S S N S S N S 1 0 0 10 2 4 18 16
Amnesty F1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S I I S I S1 S S N S S N S 1 0 0 10 2 4 18 16
Kuban kazak F2 Passed 7 0 0 6 S I I S I S1 S N S S N S 1 0 0 11 4 18 16
Kuban kazak banned R1 Passed 7 0 0 6 S I I S I S1 S N S S N S 1 0 0 11 4 18 16
SlimVirgin-Lar - Proposals (AC=11, R=1, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
CheckUser P1 Failed* 6 2 0 6 I I O R S S1 S S S O N S 15 0 0 1 2 1 2 3
User privacy and CheckUser P1.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 I I S R S S S S1 S S S N S 14 18 7 0 0 1 5 1 2
Complaints about CheckUser P2 Passed 7 1 1 6 I I S R A S S1 S S S O N S 15 19 0 0 1 9 1 2 3
...can go wherever P2.1 Failed 2 3 2 5 I I A R S O O A O S1 N 13 17 7 0 4 4 0
Privacy policy P3 Passed 9 0 0 6 I I S R S S S1 S S S S N S 15 19 0 0 1 2 1 2 3
Breaches of the privacy policy P4 Passed 6 1 2 5 I I S R A S S1 A S S O N S 15 19 0 0 1 9 1 2 3
CheckUser discretion P5 Passed 9 0 0 6 I I S R S S S S1 S S S N S 14 18 7 0 0 1 5 1 2
Focus of the case F1 Passed 9 0 0 6 I I S R S S S1 S S S S N S 15 19 0 0 9 2 1 15 3
SlimVirgin's allegations F2 Passed 5 0 4 4 I I A R A S S1 A S S A N S 15 19 0 0 9 9 1 15 3
SlimVirgin's allegations F2.1 Failed 4 0 0 6 I I R S1 S S S N 0 0 0 0
Quality of claims by SlimVirgin and Lar F2.2 Failed 3 0 0 6 I I R S1 S S N 0 0 0
Choice of forum F3 Passed 9 0 0 6 I I S R S S S1 S S S S N S 15 19 0 0 9 2 1 15 3
Lack of statement F4 Passed 7 0 2 5 I I A R S S S1 A S S S N S 15 19 0 0 9 9 1 15 3
SlimVirgin's conduct F5 Failed 5 3 1 6 I I S R O S S1 A S O O N S 15 19 0 0 9 9 19 15 3
Lar's conduct F6 Passed 8 1 0 6 I I S R S S S1 S S S O N S 15 19 0 0 9 9 1 15 3
Lar's conduct F6.1 Failed* 6 0 0 6 I I R S S S S S S1 N 4 4 0 0 0 0
Mackensen's conduct F7 Passed 9 0 0 6 I I S R S S S1 S S S S N S 15 19 0 0 9 9 1 15 3
Breach of privacy F8 Failed 2 2 3 5 I I A R O S S1 A A O N 15 19 0 0 9 1 2
Breach of privacy F8.1 Failed 3 0 2 5 I I A R S A S S1 N 0 4 4 0 0
Users reminded R1 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S R S S S1 S S S N 15 19 0 0 9 9 1
CheckUser operators reminded R2 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S R S S S1 S S S N 15 19 0 0 9 9 1
Lar and SlimVirgin general conduct R3 Failed 1 1 0 6 I I R S1 O N 0 0
Abtract-Collectonian - Proposals (AC=11, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Conduct of Wikipedia editors P1 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Harassment P2 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
"Wikistalking" P3 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Feuds and quarrels P4 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Abtract and Collectonian F2 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Harassment by Abtract F3 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Abtract's evasion of restrictions F4 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Abtract's block log F5 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Abtract's non-participation in this case F6 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Abtract restricted R1 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Interpretation of restrictions R2 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Collectonian urged R3 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 N S N S 0 6 1 0 5 5
Sarah Palin protection wheel war - Proposals (AC=11, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Administrators P1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Use of administrator tools in disputes P2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
"Ignore all rules" P3 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
"Wheel warring" P4 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Consensus P5 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Biographies of living persons P6 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Application of BLP policy P7 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Special BLP enforcement P8 Passed 7 1 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S O N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Protection of articles P9 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Pros and cons of protection P10 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Initial protection of Sarah Palin F2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
First reduction of protection by Jossi F3 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Second reduction of protection by Jossi F4 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Full protection and special BLP enforcement by MBisanz F5 Passed 7 0 1 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S A N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Reduction of protection by MZMcBride F6 Passed 7 0 1 6 I I A S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Good faith F7 Failed 3 5 0 6 I I O O S O S S1 N O O N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Parties instructed R1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Jossi admonished R2 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S S S S1 N S S N 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Jossi restricted R2.1 Failed 5 1 1 6 I I S S1 S S O N A S N 1 0 3 0 14 3 11
Jossi admonished and desysopped for 90 days R2.2 Failed 3 4 0 6 I I S S1 O O O N O S N 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Jossi desysopped R2.3 Failed 1 6 0 6 I I S1 O O O O N O O N 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
Jossi admonished and restricted for 90 days R2.4 Failed 3 2 1 6 I I S1 S O O N A S N 0 1 0 0 2 1
MZMcBride admonished R3 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S S S S1 N S S N 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
MZMcBride restricted R3.1 Failed 5 1 1 6 I I S S1 S S O N A S N 1 0 3 0 14 3 11
MZMcBride admonished and desysopped for 90 days R3.2 Failed 2 5 0 6 I I S1 O O O O N O S N 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
MZMcBride desysopped R3.3 Failed 1 6 0 6 I I S1 O O O O N O O N 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
MZMcBride admonished and restricted for 90 days R3.4 Failed 3 2 1 6 I I S1 S O O N A S N 0 1 0 0 2 1
Ongoing BLP discussion R4 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S S S1 N S S N 10 1 0 3 0 0 3 11
C68-FM-SV - Proposals (AC=9, R=2, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Decorum and civility P2 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Disputes among contributors P3 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Unnecessarily divisive behavior P4 Passed 8 0 1 5 I I A R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Tone during disputes P5 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Administrators P6 Passed 8 0 1 5 I I A R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Questioning of administrator actions P7 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Administrator judgment on issue selection P8 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Use of administrator tools in disputes P9 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Avoiding even the appearance of impropriety P10 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Harassment and threats P11 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Participation in other websites P12 Passed 8 1 0 5 I I S R O S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Consistent standards P13 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Feuds and quarrels P14 Passed 8 0 1 5 I I A R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Requests for comment P15 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Drafting requests for comment P15A Failed 1 4 3 4 I I A R A O O R O A N O S1 I 0 9 1 2 10 1 2 0
Drafting of evidence pages containing criticisms P15B Failed 1 3 2 4 I I R S1 O O R A N A O I 0 2 0 0 1 1
Minor edits P16 Passed 8 1 0 5 I I S R S S O R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Evaluating user conduct P17 Passed 8 0 1 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S A I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Circumstances and sanctions P18 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Treatment of evidence P20 Passed 7 1 0 5 I I O R S S S1 R S S N S S I 0 0 2 0 2 0 0 0
Conduct on Arbitration pages P21 Passed 8 0 0 5 I I S R S S S1 R S S N S S I 0 0 2 0 2 0 0 0
Nature of the case F1 Passed 8 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14
Cla68 F2A Passed 6 0 3 4 I I S R S A S R S S1 N S A I A 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Cla68 FB Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Cla68 FC Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Cla68 FD Passed 8 0 1 5 I I A R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Cla68 FE Failed 2 4 2 4 I I A R O A R O S1 N O O I 16 0 0 14 0 3 14
Cla68 F2E.1 Failed* 6 1 0 5 I I O R S1 S R S S N S S I 14 0 1 13 1 2 14
Cla68 F2E.2 Passed 8 0 0 5 I I S1 R S S S R S N S S I S 0 7 8 0 0 0 3 0
FeloniousMonk F3A Passed 7 0 2 4 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S A I A 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
FeloniousMonk FB Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
FeloniousMonk FC Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
FeloniousMonk FD Passed 8 0 1 5 I I A R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
FeloniousMonk FE Passed 8 0 1 5 I I S R S S A R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
FeloniousMonk FF Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
JzG F4A Passed 7 0 2 4 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S A I A 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
JzG FB Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
JzG FC Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 16 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
JzG FD Passed 8 0 1 5 I I S R A S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
JzG FE Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
SlimVirgin F5A Passed 7 0 2 4 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S A I A 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
SlimVirgin FB Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
SlimVirgin FC Passed 7 0 2 4 I I A R S S A R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
SlimVirgin FD Passed 8 1 0 5 I I S R S S O R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
SlimVirgin FE Passed 5 1 3 4 I I S R A S A R S S1 N O A I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Viridae F6A Passed 6 0 3 4 I I S R S A S R S S1 N S A I A 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Viridae FB Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Viridae FC Failed 1 5 3 4 I I A R A S1 O R O A N O O I O 14 23 0 0 14 0 3 14 17
Contentiousness and demoralization F7 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Conclusion F8 Failed 1 4 4 3 I I A R A O O R O S1 N O A I A 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Parties admonished and instructed R1 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Parties specifically instructed R2 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Further review and sanctions R3 Passed 8 1 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I O 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
Other editors counseled R4 Passed 9 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S S1 N S S I S 14 23 0 0 14 0 1 14 17
FeloniousMonk desysopped R5 Passed 8 0 0 5 I I S R S S S R S N S S1 I S 0 9 1 2 0 0 0 3
Duration of case acknowledged R6 Passed 5 1 2 4 I I S R S1 O S R S A N S A I 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1
No specific enforcement provisions at this time E1 Failed 1 4 1 5 I I R S1 O R O A N O O I 0 0 1 0 1 1
Alastair Haines - Proposals (AC=11, R=0, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Decorum P2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Editorial process P3 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Legal threats P4 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Perceived legal threats P5 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Alastair Haines F2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Ilkali F3 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
LisaLiel F4 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Alastair Haines restricted R1 Passed 7 1 0 6 I I S S O S1 S S N S S I 0 0 4 0 11 1 4 12
Ilkali restricted R2 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
LisaLiel restricted R3 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I I S S S S1 S S N S S I 0 0 0 0 11 1 4 12
Geogre-William M. Connolley - Proposals (AC=12, R=1, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Administrators P1 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S S S S1 I S 7 3 18 11 10 24 40 22 9 0 28
Wheel warring P2 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S S S S1 I S 7 3 18 11 10 24 40 22 9 0 28
Use of administrative tools in a dispute P3 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S S S S1 I S 7 3 18 11 10 24 40 22 9 0 28
DefendEachOther P4 Failed 5 3 2 6 O I R A S S O S A S O S1 I 7 3 18 11 10 24 40 22 9 0
Extending blocks P4.1 Passed 8 1 1 6 S I R S1 S S S S A O S I S 4 0 15 8 7 21 37 19 6 24
DefendEachOther P4.2 Passed 7 0 2 6 I R A S1 S S S A S S I S 12 0 6 10 6 22 4 7 9
Decorum P5 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S S S1 I S 7 3 18 11 10 24 40 9 0 28
Standard of debate P6 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S1 S S S S I S 1 20 8 1 0 14 30 12 2 17
William M. Connolley F1 Passed 10 0 1 6 S I R S S S S S A S S S1 I S 11 3 18 11 10 24 40 25 9 0 28
Geogre F2 Passed 10 0 1 6 S I R S S S S S A S S S1 I S 11 3 18 11 10 24 40 25 9 0 28
Avruch F3 Failed 0 8 0 7 O I R O O O O O O O I 3 21 9 2 2 15 32 0
Giano in Arbitration F4 Passed 7 2 1 6 S S I R S S S S1 S A O O I 14 1 20 8 1 0 14 30 36 36
Giano's comments F5 Passed 6 2 2 6 S S I R A S S S1 S A O O I 14 1 1 8 1 0 14 30 36 36
Existing remedy replaced R1 Failed 4 3 2 6 S I R S O A A O S S1 I O 7 18 11 10 40 27 10 0 28
Existing remedy replaced R1.1 Failed 5 5 0 7 S S I R S O O O O S S1 I O 24 7 18 11 10 46 27 10 0 28
Existing remedy replaced R1.2 Failed 4 4 1 6 S I R S O O A O S S1 I O 7 18 11 10 40 27 10 0 28
Existing remedy vacated R1.3 Failed 4 2 1 6 O I R S S S1 A S O I 1 8 1 0 30 17 15
Geogre's sysophood suspended for a month R2 Failed 0 6 2 6 O I R A O O O O O A I 11 3 18 11 40 27 10 0
Geogre's sysophood suspended for a fortnight R2.1 Failed 2 5 0 7 O I R S1 O O O O S I 8 0 15 8 37 24 6
Geogre cautioned to avoid wheel-warring R2.2 Failed 2 5 0 7 O I R S S1 O O O O I 7 12 0 6 22 9 7
William M. Connolley & Geogre prohibited R3 Passed 7 0 1 6 S I R S S S S A S S1 I 7 3 18 11 10 40 10 0
William M. Connolley & Geogre prohibited R3.1 Failed 4 3 1 6 S I R S1 O O S A S O I 4 0 15 8 7 37 6 7
Avruch admonished R4 Failed 1 7 0 7 O I R O O O O O O S1 I 11 30 18 11 10 40 10 0
Question remanded R5 Failed 1 8 1 6 O I R O O O S1 O A O O O I 1 1 8 1 0 14 30 17 15 1
Appeals of sanctions E1 Failed 5 0 2 6 S I R A S S A S S1 I 11 3 18 11 40 10 0
Yorkshirian - Proposals (AC=10, R=0, I=4) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S S1 S N I S S I S 7 0 1 2 0 0 7 8 5
Decorum P2 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S S1 S N I S S I S 7 0 1 2 0 0 7 8 5
Editorial process P3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S S1 S N I S S I S 7 0 1 2 0 0 7 8 5
Yorkshirian F1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S S1 S N I S S I S 7 0 1 2 0 9 7 8 5
Yorkshirian banned R1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S S1 S N I S S I S 7 0 1 2 0 9 7 8 5
Giovanni33 - Proposals (AC=11, R=1, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Sockpuppetry P1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Proxy editing P2 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Coincidental proxies P3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Concerted disruption P4 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Giovanni33 F1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Giovanni33's proxies F2 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Giovanni33 banned R1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Renewing ban R2 Failed 4 5 0 6 S R I O O O S1 O N O S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Proxy accounts banned R3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 22 10 8
Logging of bans E1 Passed 8 0 0 6 S R I S S S S1 S N S I S 13 21 21 21 0 21 10 17
Homeopathy - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 S N S S S I S 58 1 12 18 0 28 33 18 59 14
Decorum P2 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 S N S S S I S 58 1 12 18 0 28 33 18 59 14
Reliable sources P3 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 S N S S S I S 58 1 12 18 0 28 33 18 59 14
Novel approaches P4 Passed 8 1 1 6 S I S S S S1 S N O S A I S 58 1 12 18 0 28 33 18 59 14
Neutral point of view P5 Failed 1 0 0 7 I N S1 I 0
Area of conflict F1 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 S N S S S I S 58 1 12 18 0 28 33 18 59 14
DanaUllman F2 Passed 9 0 1 6 S I S S S S1 S N A S S I S 58 1 12 18 0 28 35 18 59 14
Sourcing Adjudication Board R1 Failed 6 5 0 7 O I S O S S S1 O N O S O I S 45 1 49 12 18 0 56 18 21 59 14
Expedited sanctions R2 Failed 5 5 0 7 O I S S S S1 O N O O O I S 45 1 12 18 0 56 35 56 59 14
Discretionary sanctions R3 Failed 2 4 1 6 I O O S1 O N A O S I 1 12 0 28 35 21 59
Discretionary sanctions R3.1 Passed 6 2 1 6 S I S O S S1 S N A S O I 45 18 12 18 0 28 35 21 59
DanaUllman banned R4 Passed 9 0 1 6 S I S S S S1 S N A S S I S 45 1 12 18 0 28 35 18 59 14
Footnoted quotes - Proposals (AC=11, R=0, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Biographies of living persons P1 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N S S I S 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 14 9 6
Decorum P2 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N S S I S 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 14 9 6
Role of the Arbitration Committee P3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N S S I 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 14 9
Compliance P4 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N S S I S 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 14 9 6
Novel approaches P5 Passed 9 1 0 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N O S I S 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 14 9 6
Use of quotes in footnotes P6 Failed* 8 2 0 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N O O I S 6 1 11 28 6 0 10 14 9 6
Use of quotes in footnotes P6.1 Passed 8 1 0 6 O I I S S S S S S N S S1 I 1 0 2 1 0 1 1 4 0
Problems with biographies of living persons F1 Passed 10 0 0 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N S S I S 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 14 9 6
Alansohn F3 Passed 8 0 1 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N A S I 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 15 9
Special enforcement on biographies of living persons R1 Passed 8 2 0 6 S I I S O S S S1 S N O S I S 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 15 9 6
Alansohn restricted R2 Passed 8 0 1 6 S I I S S S S S1 S N A S I 6 1 11 10 6 0 10 15 9
CAMERA lobbying - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Decorum P2 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Good intentions P3 Passed 8 0 1 6 S S A I S S S1 S N S S I 3 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Dealing with external groups P4 Passed 9 0 0 7 S S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Collective guilt P5 Passed 8 0 1 6 S S S I A S S1 S N S S I 3 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Background F1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Discretionary sanctions F2 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Sanctions imposed F3 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Hypnosadist F4 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Allegations F5 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Sanctions confirmed R1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
General amnesty R2 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Community urged R3 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Administrators commended R4 Failed 3 2 3 5 S S I A O S1 A N A O I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Hypnosadist admonished R5 Passed 8 0 0 7 S S I S S S1 S N S S I 3 10 1 1 0 10 11 11
Tango - Proposals (AC=12, R=1, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Administrators P1 Passed 9 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 S S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Use of administrative tools in a dispute P2 Passed 9 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 S S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Spirit versus letter P3 Passed 9 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 S S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Blocking P4 Failed* 8 1 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 O S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Blocking P4.1 Passed 8 1 0 7 I I S1 S S S S S R S O S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Education and warnings P5 Failed* 8 1 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 O S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Education and warnings P5.1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S S R S S1 S 1 8 8 5 5 14 0 0 0 1
Evading blocks P6 Passed 9 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 S S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Wikipedia is not Uranus (or, administrators are not Atlas) P7 Passed 7 0 1 6 I I S S S S S S R S1 A 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2
Know yourself P8 Passed 9 0 0 7 I I S1 S S S S S R S S S 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
MeatBall:DefendEachOther P9 Passed 9 1 0 7 I I S O S S S S S R S S1 S 10 8 8 0 9 14 0 8 0 1
MeatBall:DefendEachOther P9.1 Failed 6 3 0 7 I I S O O S S1 O S R S S 2 3 3 3 0 9 2 3 1
Hostile conduct directed at administrators P9.2 Failed 2 5 0 7 I I O S1 S O O O R O 4 0 3 0 6 1 0
Tango's blocks F1 Passed 9 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 S S 6 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Goa Inquisition F2 Passed 9 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S R S1 S S 6 10 0 1 16 2 0 2 3
Review and criticism F3 Passed 6 0 2 6 I I S S S A S S R S1 A 6 10 9 1 16 10 0 2
Tango R1 Failed 6 2 0 7 I I S O S S O R S1 S S 10 15 1 16 15 0 2 3
Tango R1.2 Failed* 7 1 0 7 I I S S S S O R S1 S S 10 10 14 16 14 0 2 2
Tango R1.3 Passed 7 2 0 7 I I S S S O S S R S1 O S 9 10 9 1 16 15 0 2 17
Tango advised R2 Failed 6 2 0 7 I I S S S S O S R S1 O 0 10 0 1 16 2 0 2
Prem Rawat - Proposals (AC=13, R=1, I=1) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 9 5 0 3 39
Neutral point of view and sourcing P2 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 9 5 0 3 39
Conflicts of interest P3 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 9 5 0 3 39
Consequences of a conflict of interest P4 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 9 5 0 3 39
Use of administrative tools in a content dispute P5 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Decorum P6 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Biographies of living people P7 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Summary style and content forking P8 Failed 2 6 1 7 R I A O O O O O S1 O S 17 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Locus of dispute F1 Failed 6 3 0 7 R I S S O S S O S1 O S 17 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Locus of dispute F1.1 Passed 8 0 0 7 R I S S1 S S S S S S 2 0 26 2 6 2 0 25
Small pond F2 Failed 3 3 3 6 R I A O O A S A S1 O S 17 10 5 5 21 7 0 3 39
Existing restrictions F3 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Incivility and personal attacks F4 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 17 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Jossi F5 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 42 10 5 5 21 5 0 3 39
Jossi has a self-imposed restriction F6 Failed 2 5 0 7 R I O O S O O S1 O 37 5 0 0 16 0 10
Jossi has a self-imposed restriction F6.1 Passed 8 0 1 7 R I S S1 S S S S A S S 32 0 0 0 11 0 0 5 29
Article probation R1 Passed 9 1 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 O S 42 10 5 5 41 5 0 15 39
Jossi advised R2 Failed 2 7 0 7 R I O O O S O O S1 O O 42 10 5 5 41 5 0 3 39
Editors reminded R2.1 Passed 8 0 0 7 R I S S S S1 S S S S 37 5 36 0 36 2 10 34
Editors encouraged R3 Failed 5 3 0 7 R I S S O S S O S1 O 42 10 5 5 41 5 0 3
Logging of sanctions E1 Passed 9 0 0 7 R I S S S S S S S1 S S 42 10 5 5 41 5 0 3 39
Strider12 - Proposals (AC=13, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 I S S S S 8 0 2 8 0 8 8 6 4
Decorum P2 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 I S S S S 8 0 2 8 0 8 8 6 4
Editorial process P3 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 I S S S S 8 0 2 8 0 8 8 6 4
Strider12 F1 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 I S S S S 8 0 2 8 0 8 8 6 4
Strider12 banned R1 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 I S S S S 8 0 2 8 0 8 8 6 9
Strider12 mentored R2 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I S S S S1 I S S S S 8 0 2 8 0 8 8 6 9
Betacommand 2 - Proposals (AC=13, R=1, I=1) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Means of contributing P2 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Decorum P3 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
User conduct P4 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Free and non-free content P5 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Non-free images and media P6 Passed 11 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S S S S S1 23 13 12 23 12 15 11 19 24 22 0
Non-compliant non-free media P7 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Role of editors who specialize in image review P8 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Response of users whose images are questioned P9 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Deletion of unfree images P9.1 Failed 2 8 1 7 I R S O O O O O A O O O S1 13 0 12 23 12 15 11 19 24 22 0
Role of bots and scripts P10 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Code is Law P11 Failed 1 8 1 7 I R O O O O O A O O O S1 13 12 23 12 15 11 19 24 22 0
Responsibilities of bot operators P11.1 Passed 10 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S S1 S S S 12 2 1 12 1 4 0 8 12 11
Unfree images FX Failed 0 0 0 7 I R
Betacommand F1 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12 11
Prior Arbitration case F2 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12 11
Continued participation F3 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12 11
Problematic behavior F4 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I R S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 1 0 9 12 12
Disruption F5 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12 11
Betacommand instructed R1 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12 11
Betacommand instructed R1.1 Failed 6 2 0 7 I R O S S S S1 S S O 12 1 11 0 0 8 12 10
Betacommand and editors urged R2 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12
Betacommand and editors urged R2.1 Failed 1 0 0 7 I R S1 0
Editors advised R3 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12 11
Community input R4 Passed 9 0 0 7 S I R S S S S S1 S S S 12 1 1 11 1 0 9 12 11
Review and future remedies R5 Failed 3 4 0 7 I R O S O S S1 O O 9 1 11 1 0 9 12
Review and future remedies R5.1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I R S S S S1 S S S 3 0 2 3 0 0 4 2
International Churches of Christ - Proposals (AC=13, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Editorial process P1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Edit-warring considered harmful P2 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Neutral point of view P3 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Conflict of interest P4 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Sockpuppetry and IP editing P5 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Assuming good faith P6 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Non-native speakers P7 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Disruptive editing P8 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
TransylvanianKarl F2 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Problematic editing F3 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
IP editing F4 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Additional findings F5 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Conclusions F6 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
TransylvanianKarl urged and instructed R1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
TransylvanianKarl restricted R2 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Future disruptive editing R3 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Assistance invited R4 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
Enforcement E1 Passed 8 0 0 7 S I S S S S S1 I S S 7 1 5 6 0 0 7 4
September 11 conspiracy theories - Proposals (AC=11, R=2, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I S S S R S1 S R I S S S 1 3 2 3 0 0 6 11 6
Neutral point of view P2 Passed 8 0 1 6 S I A S S R S1 S R I S S S 1 3 2 3 0 0 6 11 6
Neutral point of view P2.1 Failed 1 3 2 5 I S1 O O R A R I A O 0 0 1 0 3 3
Neutral point of view and sourcing P2.2 Failed 1 0 0 6 I R R I S1 0
Editorial process P3 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I S S S R S1 S R I S S S 1 3 2 3 0 0 6 11 6
Decorum P4 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I S S S R S1 S R I S S S 1 3 2 3 0 0 6 11 6
Sustained conflict F1 Passed 9 0 0 6 S I S S S R S1 S R I S S S 1 3 2 3 0 0 6 11 6
Discretionary sanctions R1 Passed 8 1 0 6 S I S S S R S1 S R I S S O 1 3 2 3 0 0 6 11 6
Highways 2 - Proposals (AC=12, R=1, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Consensus P1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S1 S S S R S S S S S S S 0 45 2 59 26 1 46 3 54 45 53
Consensus can change P2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S1 S S S R S S S S S S S 0 45 2 59 26 1 46 3 54 45 53
Breakdowns in consensus P3 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S1 S S S R S S S S S S S 0 45 2 59 26 1 46 3 54 45 53
Building consensus: external discussion P4 Passed 8 2 1 6 I I S1 A S O R S S S S S O S 0 45 2 59 26 1 46 3 54 45 53
Role of IRC in building consensus P4.1 Failed* 7 1 1 6 I I S A S S R S O S S1 S 0 0 1 11 0 1 1 0 5
Participation in IRC is optional P4.2 Failed 2 5 1 6 I I S O O O R A O O S1 0 0 1 11 0 1 1 0
WikiProjects P5 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S1 S S S R S S S S S S 0 45 2 59 26 1 46 3 45 53
Building consensus: WikiProjects P6 Failed 5 4 2 6 I I S1 O S A R S S O A S O O 0 45 2 59 26 1 49 3 54 45 53
Building consensus: WikiProjects P6.1 Failed 4 4 1 6 I I S S1 S O R A O S O O 0 0 1 11 0 1 4 6 4
Building consensus: WikiProjects P6.2 Passed 6 3 1 6 I I S S1 S O R A O S S O S 0 0 1 11 0 6 4 6 4 5
Ownership of articles P7 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S1 S S S R S S S S S S S 0 45 2 59 26 1 46 3 54 45 53
Guidelines P8 Passed 8 2 0 7 I I S S S S R S S O S1 O S 1 42 35 56 22 45 46 0 51 42
WikiProject status is at times useful but not critical P9 Passed 7 2 0 7 I I S S1 S O R S S S O S 0 0 0 14 3 4 7 0 8
Neutral point of view P10 Failed 5 4 1 6 I I S S1 S O R A O S O O S 0 0 0 14 3 4 7 9 0 8
Target audience P11 Failed 3 7 0 7 I I S S1 S O R O O O O O O 0 0 0 14 3 1 7 9 0 8
Use of categories and templates P12 Passed 8 2 0 7 I I S S1 S O R S S S S O S 0 0 0 14 3 9 4 9 0 8
Inconsistencies are a feature of the real world P13 Failed 5 4 0 7 I I S S1 S O R S O S O O 0 0 0 14 3 4 4 0 8
Excessive focus P14 Failed 4 5 0 7 I I S S1 S O R S O O O O 0 0 0 14 3 4 7 0 8
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S1 S S R S S S S S S S 0 45 59 26 49 49 49 54 45 60
Good faith F2 Failed 3 5 1 6 I I S S1 O O R S O O O A 4 0 0 14 4 4 7 0 15
... in their contributions F2.1 Failed 5 4 0 7 I I S S S1 O R S O O S O 1 0 0 14 4 7 7 19 7
Road-related consistency F3 Failed 2 5 1 6 I I A S1 O O R S O O O 0 0 0 14 4 7 7 0
Imperfectly inconsistent policy application is a fact of life F3.1 Failed 4 4 0 7 I I S S S1 O R S O O O 3 0 0 14 5 7 7 7
Inconsistency in content F3.2 Failed 6 2 0 7 I I S O O S R S S S1 S 3 4 13 7 0 0 0 8
NE2 F4 Failed 4 6 0 7 I I S S1 S O R S O O O O O 0 0 0 14 4 7 8 19 0 15
Spill-over F5 Passed 9 1 0 7 I I S S1 S S R S S S S S O 0 0 0 14 4 7 7 19 0 15
USRD editors F7 Failed 2 1 0 7 I I R S S1 O 3 0 4
Editors counselled R1 Passed 8 2 0 7 I I S1 S S O R S S S S S O 0 42 35 56 22 46 49 50 61 42
NE2 admonished R2 Failed 5 5 0 7 I I S S1 S O R S O S O O O 0 0 0 14 4 7 8 19 3 15
WikiProject members encouraged R3 Failed 6 2 0 7 I I S S1 S O R S S S O 0 0 0 14 4 7 8 0
USRD members advised R4 Passed 7 0 0 7 I I S S R S S S S1 S 3 1 3 6 3 0 4
Future concerns E1 Failed 2 6 0 7 I I S1 O O R S O O O O 0 0 14 4 7 8 19 0
Formal enforcement measures not imposed on any editor this time E1.1 Passed 8 0 1 6 I I S S1 S S R S S S S A 4 0 4 14 4 7 8 19 8
Franco-Mongol alliance - Proposals (AC=12, R=1, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Reliability of content P2 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Sourcing P3 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Accuracy of sourcing P4 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Neutral point of view P5 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Problematic editing P6 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Misrepresentation of sources F2 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
Reactions to questioning F3 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
PHG restricted R1 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
PHG reminded R2 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
PHG encouraged R3 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 1 2
PHG reminded: collaborative consensus R4 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 S S S R 0 3 2 1 0 0 0 0
Enforcement E1 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S R 2 4 1 1 3 0 2 2
Mantanmoreland - Proposals (AC=13, R=1, I=1) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 1 0 9 1 1 1 11
Integrity of content P2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 1 0 9 1 1 1 11
Sockpuppetry P3 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Evaluating sockpuppetry P4 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Evaluating sockpuppetry P4.1 Failed 6 4 0 7 I S S1 S O R O S S S O O 7 0 13 2 8 0 9 0 1 1
Off-wiki disputes P5 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 1 0 9 1 1 1 11
Conduct on Arbitration pages P6 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 1 0 9 1 1 1 11
Purpose of Arbitration P7 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 9 0 9 1 1 1 11
Limitations of Arbitration P8 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 0 13 2 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Enabling P9 Failed 3 2 5 5 I S1 S A R O A A S A O A 0 13 2 8 0 9 0 1 1 11
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 12 0 0 7 I S S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 13 8 0 13 2 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Locus of dispute F1.1 Failed 2 5 3 6 I S S1 O O R O A A O O A 13 0 13 2 8 0 0 1 1 11
Allegations F2 Failed* 7 3 0 7 I S S S O R O S1 O S S S 8 0 13 2 8 0 9 1 1 1
Allegations F2.1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S1 S S S R S S S S S S 0 4 5 0 1 0 1 0 3 3
Impact of dispute F3 Passed 9 1 0 7 I S O S R S S1 S S S S S 8 12 13 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Impact of dispute F3.1 Failed* 8 0 2 6 I S1 S S R A A S S S S S 0 13 8 8 0 9 0 1 1 11
Impact of dispute F3.2 Failed 5 0 0 7 I S S1 S R S S 1 0 1 1 1
Effect of change to open proxy policy F4 Failed 2 1 2 6 I A S1 O R A S 0 0 1 0 0
Editors instructed R1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 1 13 9 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Article probation R2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 1 13 9 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Review of articles R3 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 1 13 9 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Mantanmoreland topic ban R4 Passed 9 0 0 7 I S1 S S S R S S S S S 0 4 5 1 1 0 1 0 3
Topic ban R4.1 Failed* 7 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S S1 0 1 2 0 0 0 0
Mantanmoreland instructed R5 Passed 9 1 0 7 I S S S O R S S1 S S S S 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 1 0 1
Enforcement E1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 11 13 9 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Interpretation E2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S S S S 8 11 13 9 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Serious violations and circumstances E3 Passed 9 1 1 7 I S S S S R S S1 S S A O S 8 11 13 9 8 0 9 1 1 1 11
Ehud Lesar - Proposals (AC=14, R=0, I=1) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Banned users P1 Failed 2 7 0 8 I O O O O O S O S1 O 2 28 31 10 13 14 21 0 32
Banned users P1.1 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S1 S S S S S S S S S S S 0 19 26 29 8 10 11 19 18 20 30 10
Determination of sockpuppetry P2 Passed 10 2 0 8 I S S S S S S S S S1 O O S 3 22 28 31 10 13 14 21 0 22 32 13
Sockpuppetry P2.1 Passed 8 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S 6 9 4 0 11 0 0 10
AdilBaguirov is a banned user F1 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S S S1 S S S 3 22 28 31 10 13 14 21 0 22 32 13
Ehud Lesar F2 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S S S1 S S S 3 22 28 31 10 13 14 22 0 22 32 13
Block disputed F3 Failed 3 4 2 7 I S1 A O O S S A O O 0 19 25 28 7 10 11 19 29
Sockpuppet status disputed F3.1 Passed 8 0 0 8 I S S S S1 S S S S 6 9 3 0 0 0 1 10
Ehud Lesar has not been demonstrated to be a sockpuppet of AdilBaguirov F4 Passed 8 2 0 8 I S S S O S S O S1 S S 15 22 32 31 10 14 28 0 22 32
Ehud Lesar is a sockpuppet of AdilBaguirov F5 Failed 1 7 1 7 I O O A O O O O O S1 15 22 28 31 10 14 0 22 13
The sockpuppetry accusations were made in good faith F6 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S1 S S S S S S S S S 0 2 8 11 1 1 8 0 12 11
Ehud Lesar unbanned R1 Passed 9 0 1 7 I S S S S S S A S1 S S 15 22 28 31 10 14 31 0 22 32
Ehud Lesar banned R2 Failed 1 8 1 7 I O O O O O A O O O S1 15 22 31 10 14 31 0 22 32 13
Episodes and characters 2 - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Editorial process P1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Struggle P2 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Fait accompli P3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Decorum P4 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Compliance P5 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Unclear status F2 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Poor behavior F3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Non-compliance F4 Failed 2 2 1 6 I I S O S1 I A O 13 15 0 11 22
Non-compliance F4.1 Passed 9 1 0 7 I I S S S S S I S S S1 O S 0 2 4 1 1 0 7 0 11 8
TTN restricted R1 Failed 3 2 3 5 I I A S S S1 I A O A O 11 13 15 0 11 18 11 22
TTN restricted R1.1 Passed 9 1 0 7 I I S S S S S I S1 S S O S 0 2 4 0 0 0 7 0 11 7
Parties instructed and warned R2 Passed 9 1 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S O S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S1 I S S S S S 11 13 15 11 0 11 18 11 22 18
Waterboarding - Proposals (AC=11, R=1, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Decorum P2 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Editorial process P3 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Dispute resolution P4 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Content disputes P5 Passed 6 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Article probation R1 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
General restriction R2 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Logging of sanctions E1 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Enforcement by block E2 Passed 7 0 0 6 I I S S R S1 I S S S S 4 3 0 0 11 5 11
Bluemarine - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=3) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Decorum P1 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Conflict of interest P2 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Ownership of articles P3 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Biographies of living people P4 Failed* 6 0 2 6 I I S A A S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Subjects of articles P5 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Two wrongs do not make a right P6 Failed 2 3 2 6 I I A O O S I A S1 O 1 1 5 0 0 0 9
Dealing with harassed editors P6.1 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 0 4 0 0 0 8 4
Bluemarine has edited with a conflict of interest F1 Failed 4 2 1 6 I I A O S S I S S1 O 1 1 5 0 0 0 9
Bluemarine has been incivil and made personal attacks F2 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Bluemarine is a victim of harassment F3 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Matt Sanchez has been edited in violation of Biographies of Living People policy F4 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Bluemarine banned R1 Passed 8 0 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 S S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Article probation R2 Passed 7 1 0 7 I I S S S S I S S1 O S 1 1 5 0 0 0 9 5
Discretionary sanctions R2.1 Failed 3 3 1 6 I I S O O S I A S1 O 3 8 3 0 1 0 7
Appeal of discretionary sanctions R3 Failed 3 3 1 6 I I S O O S I A S1 O 3 8 3 0 1 0 7
Enforcement by block E1 Failed 4 3 0 7 I I S O S S1 I S O O 1 1 5 0 0 2 9
Palestine-Israel articles - Proposals (AC=13, R=0, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S S 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Decorum P2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S S 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Editorial process P3 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S S 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Dispute resolution P4 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S S 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Area of conflict F1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S S 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Choice of approach F2 Failed 2 4 1 7 I I S1 O O A S O O 0 1 0 1 1 0 1
Discretionary sanctions R1 Failed 6 3 0 7 I I S S S O S S1 S O O 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 2 3
Discretionary sanctions R1.1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S S1 S S S S 3 2 1 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Appeal of discretionary sanctions R2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S S 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Working group R3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S 3 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3
Editors reminded R4 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S S1 S S S S 0 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Editors counseled R5 Passed 10 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S S1 S S S 0 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3
Logging of sanctions E1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I I S S S S S S1 S S S S S 1 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 2 3 3
Uninvolved administrators E2 Passed 8 2 1 7 I I O S A S S S1 S O S S S 3 2 2 2 2 0 0 3 4 3 3
Zeraeph - Proposals (AC=11, R=2, I=2) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Decorum P1 Passed 9 0 0 6 I S R S S S S1 S R I S S S 4 1 8 8 0 0 2 8 9
External conduct P2 Passed 9 0 0 6 I S R S S S S1 S R I S S S 4 1 8 8 0 0 2 8 9
Casting aspersions P3 Passed 9 0 0 6 I S R S S S S1 S R I S S S 4 1 8 8 0 0 2 8 9
External matters P4 Failed 1 0 1 6 I R S1 R I A 0 0
Zeraeph F1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I R S S S S1 S R I S S S 1 9 8 0 0 2 8 9
Evidence of harassment F2 Failed 4 1 1 6 I R O S1 S R I A S S 8 0 0 8 8 9
SandyGeorgia's conduct F2.1 Failed 3 3 0 6 I R O O S R I S1 O S 1 1 0 0 1 1
Zeraeph banned R1 Passed 8 0 0 6 I R S S S S1 S R I S S S 1 9 8 0 0 8 8 9
John Gohde 2 - Proposals (AC=14, R=0, I=1) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Decorum P1 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S1 S S S S S S S 3 2 1 6 0 5 0 6 1 5 5 3
Dispute resolution P2 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S1 S S S S S S S 3 2 1 6 0 5 0 6 1 5 5 3
Purpose of Wikipedia P3 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S1 S S S S S S S 3 2 1 6 0 5 0 6 1 5 5 3
Recidivism P4 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S1 S S S S S S S 3 2 1 6 0 5 0 6 1 5 5 3
John Gohde F1 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S1 S S S S S S S 3 2 1 6 0 5 0 6 1 5 5 3
John Gohde banned R1 Passed 12 0 0 8 I S S S S S1 S S S S S S S 5 2 1 6 0 5 0 6 1 5 5 3
John Gohde sanctions upon return R2 Failed 3 4 2 7 I O S O O A S A O S1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Jim62sch - Proposals (AC=14, R=0, I=1) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flo FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mor New Pau Sam Ste Uni Yel
Harassment P1 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 2
Perceived harassment P2 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Threats P3 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Conduct outside Wikipedia P4 Passed 9 0 1 7 I S A S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Raising good-faith concerns P5 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Compliance with basic policy P6 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Circumstances P7 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
No legal advice P8 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Conduct on Arbitration pages P9 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Jim62sch F1 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Subsequent conduct F2 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Additional factors F3 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Other editors F4 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Underlying issue F5 Failed 3 4 2 7 I O A O O S O S1 A S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0
Jim62sch instructed R1 Failed 3 4 0 8 I O O O S O S1 S 1 2 1 0 1 0 0
Jim62sch instructed R1.1 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S1 S S S S S S S S S 0 2 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1
Editors reminded R2 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Jim62sch E1 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Harassment and threats E2 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Grave real-world harassment E3 Passed 10 0 0 8 I S S S S S S S1 S S S 1 3 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 2
Proposals: 729; passed: 530 (73%); failed: 199 (27%).

For cases involving 2008 and departing 2007 arbs[edit]

Proposals for cases involving 2008 and departing 2007 arbs
Matthew Hoffman - Proposals (AC=11, R=1, I=5) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel
Administrators P1 Failed 5 2 0 6 R N N I S S S O O I I S I N I N S1 0 5 53 7 6 6 0
Administrators P1.1 Passed 6 2 1 6 R N N I S S A O S1 I S I O I N I N S 0 0 47 49 0 11 49 0
Administrators P1.2 Failed 4 0 0 6 R N N I S S I I S1 I N I N S 0 0 0 2
Don't bite the newcomers P2 Passed 9 0 0 6 R N N I S S S S S S I S I S I N I N S1 0 5 53 7 54 6 16 6 0
Blocking policy P3 Failed 3 3 0 6 R N N I O S O O I I S I N I N S1 0 5 7 6 6 0
Blocking policy P3.1 Failed 4 1 1 6 R N N I S S O A I I S I N I N S1 3 46 2 1 0 0
Blocking of sock puppets P4 Passed 9 0 0 6 R N N I S S S S S S I S I S I N I N S1 0 5 53 7 54 6 16 6 0
Review and discussion of blocks P5 Passed 9 0 0 6 R N N I S S S S S S I S I S I N I N S1 0 5 53 6 54 5 16 6 0
Know yourself P6 Passed 8 0 0 6 R N N I S S1 S S S S I S I S I N I N 0 0 47 1 49 0 11 0
Administrators: use of administrative tools in a dispute P7 Passed 8 0 0 6 R N N I S S S S S S1 I S I S I N I N 0 0 47 1 49 0 11 0
Confirmation bias in block reviews P8 Passed 9 0 0 6 R N N I S S S S S S I S I S I N I N S1 4 3 46 2 47 1 10 0 0
Feedback P9 Failed 0 5 0 6 R N N I O O O I I O I N I N O 0 44 0 43 1
Vanished user F1 Failed 3 2 0 6 R N N I O S O I I S I N I N S1 0 5 7 6 0
Vanished user F1.1 Passed 9 0 0 6 R N N I S1 S S S S S I S I S I N I N S 0 0 47 1 49 3 11 47 0
Edit history of Irreducible complexity F2 Failed 3 2 0 6 R N N I S O O I I S I N I N S1 5 7 6 6 0
History of Irreducible complexity F2.1 Passed 8 0 0 6 R N N I S S S1 S S I S I S I N I N S 0 46 0 48 2 10 2 0
Vanished user's statements about Hoffman not borne out by the facts F3 Passed 8 0 0 6 R N N I S S S S S I S I S I N I N S1 5 53 7 54 5 16 6 0
72 hour and indefinite blocks of Matthew Hoffman were outside policy F4 Passed 8 0 0 6 R N N I S S S S S I S I S I N I N S1 5 53 6 54 5 16 6 0
Matthew Hoffman not a sock puppet F5 Passed 7 0 1 6 R N N I S A S S S I S I S I N I N S1 5 53 6 54 5 16 6 0
User:Chaser F6 Failed 1 1 0 6 R N N I S1 O I I I N I N 0 4
Hot button F7 Failed 1 4 0 6 R N N I S1 O O O I I O I N I N 0 48 1 0 0
MatthewHoffman F8 Failed 2 2 0 6 R N N I S1 O S I I O I N I N 0 1 0 0
Vanished user's use of administrative tools F9 Failed 5 2 1 6 R N N I S O S S O I S I A I N I N S1 1 46 1 46 64 8 45 0
Vanished user's use of administrative tools F9.1 Passed 6 0 1 6 R N N I S S1 S S I I A S I N I N S 13 0 0 0 0 13 2
External coordination F10 Failed 2 4 1 6 R N N I S1 A O O I S I O I N I N O 0 43 45 7 7 43 46
Vanished user desysopped R1 Failed 3 2 1 6 R N N I O O A S I I S I N I N S1 0 5 53 8 6 0
... RfA possible too R1.1 Failed 4 2 1 6 R N N I O A S O S1 I I S I N I N S 45 45 1 46 0 0 0
MatthewHoffman R2 Passed 7 1 0 6 R N N I O S S S S I I S S I N I N S1 5 53 6 54 8 54 6 0
Vanished user cautioned R3 Failed 3 3 1 6 R N N I S S1 A S O I I O I N I N O 0 0 48 1 3 47 3
Vanished user provisionally desysopped for six months R4 Passed 7 2 0 6 R N N I S O S1 S S S I I O S I N I N S 0 1 0 2 1 0 2 1 1
IRC - Proposals (AC=12, R=2, I=6) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel
Wikipedians are expected to observe dispute resolution guidelines P1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S N I S S S R S S I S I S S I S I R S1 0 1 2 0 1 0 0 0 30 1 0
Reversion not a substitute for discussion P2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S N I S S S R S S I S I S S I S I R S1 0 1 2 0 1 0 0 0 30 1 0
Reversion not a substitute for discussion P2.1 Failed* 10 0 0 7 I N I S S S1 R S S I S I S S I S I R S 1 2 0 1 0 30 0 30 1 2
Disruption by administrators P3.2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I S N I S S S1 R S S I S I S S I S I R S 1 1 2 0 1 0 5 0 30 1 2
Administrative tools P3.3 Failed* 8 1 0 7 I N I O S S1 R S I S I S S I S I R S 5 0 0 2 29 0 28 29 0
Pages are not owned P4 Passed 8 2 0 7 I S N I O S R O S I S I S S I S I R S1 0 5 0 12 0 0 0 30 1 0
Scope of communal editing P4.1 Failed 4 5 1 6 I S N I S S S1 R O O I I A O I O I R O 9 5 0 0 11 2 0 28 29 0
Decorum P5 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S N I S S S R S S1 I I S S I S I R S 0 1 2 0 1 0 0 30 23 2
Decorum P5.1 Failed* 8 1 0 7 I S N I S S S R S1 I I S O I S I R S 19 1 1 1 0 0 29 22 1
Decorum: fair criticism P6 Passed 10 0 0 7 I S N I S S S R S S1 I I S S I S I R S 0 1 2 0 1 0 0 30 23 2
Criticism P6.1 Failed* 7 1 0 7 I S N I S S R S1 I I S O I S I R S 19 1 1 0 0 29 22 1
Decorum and discussion P7 Failed 2 6 1 6 I N I O S S1 R O O I I A O I O I R O 0 1 0 1 0 0 30 23 2
Dispute resolution P8 Failed 5 2 0 7 I N I S S R S1 I I S O I S I R O 1 1 0 0 29 22 1
Provocative actions P9 Passed 8 1 0 7 I N I S S S1 R S S I I S S I S I R O 5 0 0 11 2 0 28 22 0
The community has a forward-looking approach to interpersonal disputes P10 Failed 6 3 0 7 I N I S S S1 R O S I I S O I S I R O 5 0 0 11 2 0 28 22 0
Wheel warring P12 Failed 5 5 0 7 I O N I S S S1 R O S I I S O I O I R O 23 5 0 0 11 2 0 28 22 0
Warlike behavior using administrative tools P12.1 Passed 7 2 1 6 I S N I S S S1 R O S I I A O I S I R S 23 24 3 0 10 1 1 28 21 1
Bad Blood P15 Passed 7 3 0 7 I S N I S S S1 R S S I I S O I O I R O 9 5 0 0 10 2 0 28 21 0
Policy issues surrounding IRC P17 Passed 7 1 0 7 I N I S S R S S I I S O I S I R S1 0 7 0 0 0 13 6 0
WP:IRC/WEA F2 Failed 2 0 2 6 I N I R I I A S I A I R S1 0 13 10 0
Locus of dispute F3 Failed 3 1 0 7 I N I S1 R I I O I S I R S 0 12 13 0
Locus of dispute F3.1 Failed 3 1 0 7 I N I S1 R I I O I S I R S 0 11 8 11
Giano F4 Passed 9 1 0 7 I S N I S S R S S I S I S O I S I R S1 0 18 2 12 0 0 0 30 26 24
Bishonen F5 Failed 4 4 0 7 I N I S R O S I S I O O I O I R S1 2 12 0 0 0 30 26 0
Geogre F6 Passed 7 2 0 7 I S N I S R S S I S I O O I S I R S1 17 2 12 0 0 0 30 26 0
David Gerard F7.1 Passed 6 0 2 6 I S N I S R S S I I A S I A I R S1 13 0 0 0 0 13 16 0
Tony Sidaway F8 Failed 6 1 0 7 I S N I S1 R S I I S S I O I R S 1 0 1 0 12 8 0
Phil Sandifer F9 Failed 2 4 0 7 I N I S1 R S I I O O I O I R O 0 0 1 12 8 4
Comments by Tony Sidaway and Phil Sandifer F10 Failed 2 2 2 6 I N I S1 R S I I A O I A I R O 0 0 0 12 8 4
Status of #wikipedia-en-admins F11 Failed 2 2 0 7 I N I R I I S S1 I O I R O 0 0 4 3
The "admin" IRC has been a source of conflict F12 Failed 6 1 0 7 I S N I S R S I I S S1 I S I R O 3 3 3 0 0 4 3
Edit-warring occurred F13 Passed 7 0 0 7 I S N I S R S I I S S1 I S I R S 3 3 3 0 0 4 3
Giano II R2 Failed 2 9 0 7 I O N I O S R O O I O I O O I O I R S1 O 2 5 7 0 0 13 0 13 10 0 0
Giano II R2.1 Failed 5 6 0 7 I S N I O S R S S I O I O O I O I R S1 O 2 5 7 0 0 13 0 13 16 0 0
Civility: Giano R2.2 Passed 7 3 0 7 I S N I S1 O R S S I S I O O I S I R S 2 0 5 14 8 11 11 11 8 3
Geogre R3 Failed 3 8 0 7 I O N I O S R O O I O I O O I S I R S1 O 7 5 7 0 0 13 0 13 10 0 0
Bishonen R4 Failed 2 7 0 7 I N I S R O O I O I O O I O I R S1 O 7 0 0 13 0 13 10 0 0
David Gerard R5 Failed 4 4 2 6 I O N I O S R S A I O I O S I A I R S1 13 0 7 0 0 13 0 13 10 0
IRC R6 Passed 9 0 1 6 I S N I S S R S S I S I S A I S I R S1 7 0 7 0 0 13 0 13 10 0
Communication restricted R7 Failed 1 8 0 7 I O N I S1 O R O O I O I O I O I R O 5 0 5 0 8 11 11 8 3
Civility: Tony Sidaway R9 Failed 3 3 2 6 I S N I S R S1 I O I A A I O I R O 2 1 0 11 0 11 8 11
Civility: Geogre R11 Failed 1 6 0 7 I O N I S1 R O I O I O O I O I R 2 5 0 11 0 11 8
All parties cautioned R13 Passed 8 0 0 7 I N I S1 R S S I S I S S I S I R S 0 0 0 4 0 3 0 0
Final warning: Giano R14 Failed 3 5 1 6 I O N I S1 R O S I O I A O I S I R O 1 0 0 0 4 0 3 0 0
Editors are requested R15 Passed 7 1 0 7 I S N I S R S I S I S S1 I S I R O 5 3 7 3 6 0 4 3
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 7 0 0 7 I S N I S R S S1 I S I I S I R S 1 0 1 0 3 0 3
Dbachmann - Proposals (AC=13, R=0, I=5) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel
Purpose of Wikipedia P1 Passed 11 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 0 6 7 2 9 9 3
Decorum P2 Passed 11 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 0 6 7 2 9 9 3
Editorial process P3 Passed 11 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 0 6 7 2 9 9 3
Administrators P4 Passed 11 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 0 6 7 2 9 9 3
Administrators: use of administrative tools in a dispute P5 Passed 11 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 0 6 7 2 9 9 3
Rollback P6 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S S I S S I N I S1 S 0 2 4 5 0 4 0 0 0 0
Locus of dispute F1 Failed* 11 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 0 6 7 2 9 9 3
Locus of dispute F1.1 Passed 12 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S S S S I S1 S I N I S S 1 10 12 5 5 0 4 5 0 8 8 1
Bakasuprman F2 Failed 6 4 1 7 I N N I S O S S O S1 S I S O I N I A O 3 11 13 7 4 0 6 2 9 13 3
Deeceevoice F3 Failed 6 4 1 7 I N N I S O S S O S1 S I S O I N I A O 3 11 13 7 4 0 6 2 9 13 3
Dbachmann F4 Failed* 8 2 0 7 I N N I S S S O S1 S I S S I N I S O 3 1 7 4 0 6 2 9 9 3
Dbachmann F4.1 Passed 9 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S S I S S I N I S1 0 2 4 5 1 4 0 4 0
Bakasuprman banned R1 Failed 3 5 1 7 I N N I O O S O S1 I S O I N I A O 13 11 7 4 0 2 9 13 3
Bakasuprman restricted R1.1 Failed 5 4 1 7 I N N I S O S S O S I S1 O I N I A O 1 10 12 5 2 0 0 8 11 1
Deeceevoice banned R2 Failed 4 4 2 6 I N N I S O A S O S1 I S O I N I A O 8 11 13 7 4 0 2 9 13 3
Dbachmann admonished R3 Failed* 8 4 0 7 I N N I S S S S O S1 O S I S O I N I S O 3 1 13 7 4 0 13 7 2 9 13 3
Dbachmann reminded R3.1 Passed 9 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S S I S S1 I N I S 0 2 5 5 0 4 1 0 3
Article probation R4 Passed 12 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 4 0 13 7 2 9 9 3
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 12 0 0 7 I N N I S S S S S S1 S S I S S I N I S S 3 1 13 7 4 0 13 7 2 10 9 3
John Buscema - Proposals (AC=12, R=0, I=5) Disp S O A M Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel Cha Des Fay Flc Flo Fre FT2 Jdf Jpg kir Mac Mor Neu New Pau Rau Sam Sim Ste Uni Yel
Editorial process P1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Edit-warring considered harmful P2 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Assume good faith and remain civil P3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Page protection P4 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Role of the Arbitration Committee P5 Failed 3 5 1 6 I N N I S A N S O O I S1 O I N I O O 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7
Role of the Arbitration Committee P5.1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S1 I S S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Locus of dispute F1 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Competing editorial visions F2 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Edit-war F3 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
Continued disputes and protection F4 Passed 10 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7 3
User conduct F5 Failed 4 4 1 6 I N N I O S N O O S I S1 O I N I A S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 7 3
Editing of John Buscema R1 Failed 3 6 0 7 I N N I O O N O O S I S1 S I N I O O 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7
Subsequent editing R2 Passed 7 1 1 6 I N N I S O N S S S I S1 S I N I S A 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7
Disruptive editing R3 Passed 8 1 0 7 I N N I S O N S S S I S1 S I N I S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7
Editing of John Buscema R4 Failed 2 5 0 7 I N N I O N O S1 O I O I N I O S 0 3 0 0 0 3 5
Editing of John Buscema R4.1 Failed* 8 0 0 7 I N N I S1 N S S S I S S I N I S S 0 3 0 0 0 5 3 5
Enforcement by block E1 Passed 9 0 0 7 I N N I S S N S S S I S1 S I N I S S 2 0 5 0 0 0 7 5 7
Proposals: 112; passed: 57 (51%); failed: 55 (49%).
  • Failed*: Although receiving enough supports to pass, the proposal failed due either to preferential or conditional voting.

Arb activity[edit]

Legend[edit]

In the two tables below, the column headings have the following meanings:

  • EP (eligible proposals): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was eligible to act (count of non-"N"s).
  • I (inactive): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as inactive/away (count of "I"s); as a percentage of EP.
  • R (recused): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as recused (count of "R"s); as a percentage of (EPI).
  • V (voted): The total number of proposals this arb voted to support or oppose (count of "S"s or "O"s); as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • A (abstained): The total number of proposals for which this arb abstained (count of "A"s), as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • DNA (did not act): The total number of proposals in cases for which this arb was listed on the case's "Proposed decision" talk page as active, but did not act (count of empty cells); as a percentage of (EP - (I + R)).
  • S (supported): The total number of proposals this arb supported (count of "S"s); as a percentage of V.
  • O (opposed): The total number of proposals this arb opposed (count of "O"s); as a percentage of V.
  • FS (first support): The number of times this arb was first to support the proposal, which is generally indicative of having drafted the proposal (count of "S1"s); as a percentage of total number of proposals drafted.
  • ATV (average (mean) time to vote), MTV (median time to vote): For all the proposals this arb acted on (i.e. supported, opposed, or abstained), the average (mean) and the median of the length of time (in days) between the first action on the proposal and this arb's action on the proposal.

Arb activity (2008)[edit]

Arb activity (2008) — case proposals
Arb EP I % R % V % A % DNA % S % O % FS % ATV MTV
Charles Matthews 729 367 50% 51 14% 178 57% 23 7% 110 35% 166 93% 12 7% 0 0% 10.1 8.0
Deskana 663 500 75% 10 6% 98 64% 0 0% 55 36% 76 78% 22 22% 3 0% 5.3 4.0
FayssalF 617 197 32% 35 8% 159 41% 22 6% 204 53% 152 96% 7 4% 4 1% 9.6 10.0
FloNight 729 15 2% 105 15% 553 91% 17 3% 39 6% 510 92% 43 8% 32 4% 3.8 1.0
FT2 712 26 4% 0 0% 266 39% 25 4% 395 58% 249 94% 17 6% 46 6% 12.7 4.0
Jdforrester 729 0 0% 46 6% 608 89% 16 2% 59 9% 529 87% 79 13% 12 2% 5.8 5.0
Jpgordon 729 100 14% 18 3% 465 76% 6 1% 140 23% 377 81% 88 19% 3 0% 7.8 3.0
Kirill Lokshin 729 0 0% 118 16% 578 95% 10 2% 23 4% 530 92% 48 8% 257 35% 1.3 0.0
Morven 729 40 5% 0 0% 392 57% 16 2% 281 41% 347 89% 45 11% 1 0% 10.5 10.0
Newyorkbrad 676 6 1% 16 2% 495 76% 79 12% 80 12% 442 89% 53 11% 213 29% 3.6 0.0
Paul August 489 40 8% 0 0% 368 82% 13 3% 68 15% 280 76% 88 24% 6 1% 12.9 9.0
Sam Blacketer 663 0 0% 20 3% 591 92% 24 4% 28 4% 516 87% 75 13% 27 4% 5.7 5.0
Stephen Bain 699 0 0% 46 7% 453 69% 33 5% 167 26% 394 87% 59 13% 71 10% 14.1 11.0
UninvitedCompany 538 149 28% 0 0% 291 75% 6 2% 92 24% 211 73% 80 27% 40 5% 6.4 3.0
YellowMonkey 729 0 0% 14 2% 349 49% 23 3% 343 48% 311 89% 38 11% 2 0% 15.9 14.0

Arb activity (departing 2007)[edit]

Arb activity (departing 2007) — case proposals
Arb EP I % R % V % A % DNA % S % O % FS % ATV MTV
Flcelloguy 112 112 100% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0%
Fred Bauder 112 0 0% 0 0% 92 82% 1 1% 19 17% 76 83% 16 17% 7 6% 3.1 1.0
Mackensen 112 76 68% 0 0% 16 44% 0 0% 20 56% 15 94% 1 6% 0 0% 6.8 6.0
Neutrality 112 112 100% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0%
Raul654 112 112 100% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0%
SimonP 112 112 100% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0%